Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, May 2002, p. 2326-2329, Vol. 68, No. 5
0099-2240/02/$04.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/AEM.68.5.2326-2329.2002
Copyright © 2002, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Plant Mycotoxin Research Unit, Western Regional Research Center, USDA Agricultural Research Service, Albany, California 94710,1 Department of Plant Pathology, Kearney Agricultural Center, University of California, Davis, Parlier, California 936482
Received 9 April 2001/ Accepted 15 December 2001
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fungi from two genera are known to produce ochratoxins: the Aspergillus species A. ochraceus, A. melleus, A. auricomus, A. ostianus, A. petrakii, A. sclerotiorum, and A. sulfureus, all in section Circumdati (also called the A. ochraceus group); A. alliaceus and A. albertensis, formerly placed in section Circumdati but recently shown to be more closely related to section Flavi (18); A. niger and A. carbonarius (in section Nigri); A. glaucus (or Eurotium herbariorum [section Aspergillus]); and Penicillium verrucosum (1, 4, 12, 18, 19, 24, 26). Several of these species are synonymous or poorly defined, which complicates analysis of ochratoxin contamination of crops (18, 28).
Few of these species are known to contaminate foods with ochratoxin A. According to Pitt (20), ochratoxin A "is produced by Penicillium verrucosum in cereal grains in cold climates, by A. carbonarius in grapes, wines and vine fruits, and by Aspergillus ochraceus sometimes in coffee beans." However, because few geographic areas have been studied, because many fungi are capable of producing ochratoxins, and because of taxonomic problems in section Circumdati, it is not always clear which species are responsible for ochratoxin contamination of crops and commodities. This is particularly true of North America, where studies on ochratoxins in crops have focused on Penicillium verrucosum contamination of cereals (17, 20).
Our objectives in this study were (i) to determine the frequency of different members of the A. ochraceus group in tree nuts and figs in California, (ii) to determine which species produce ochratoxin A and to estimate the frequency of ochratoxinogenic isolates among these species, and (iii) to determine which species are responsible for ochratoxin in figs. Since California nut and fig crops have never been reported to contain the levels of ochratoxin found in wheat and other crops (10, 11, 17, 20), we hypothesized that populations of ochratoxin-producing species would be dominated by atoxigenic strains.
|
|
|---|
To determine whether the A. ochraceus group or Penicillium verrucosum was responsible for ochratoxin contamination of crops, we collected dried figs from 10 commercial orchards in Fresno, Madera, and Merced counties. Ten thousand figs were collected in 1997, and 20,000 each in 1998 and 1999. Figs were halved and examined with a dissecting microscope for the presence of fungal colonies (10). Because the large sample size made it impractical to analyze each fig separately, figs were pooled for ochratoxin analysis. For each year, all figs visibly infected with Penicillium spp. were pooled for analysis. Figs infected with the A. ochraceus group were pooled by orchard for analysis. Penicillium isolates were not identified to species level.
For ochratoxin analyses in vitro, fungi were grown in 50 ml of liquid medium in 125-ml Erlenmeyer flasks. Two media were used: potato dextrose broth (PDB; Difco) and yeast extract-sucrose broth (YES; 2% yeast extract, 15% sucrose) (26). Cultures were incubated without agitation for 10 days at 30°C in the dark. Then 2 ml of culture fluid was removed from each flask, filtered through a 0.2-µm syringe filter, and extracted with 2 ml of chloroform. The organic phase was collected, evaporated, and resuspended in 500 µl of methanol. Then 20 µl was injected into a high-performance liquid chromatograph (HPLC model 1050; Hewlett Packard, Palo Alto, Calif.) with model 1046A fluorescence detector (Hewlett Packard). The HPLC was run on a VYDAC 218TP54 C18 column (4.6 by 250 mm; VYDAC/The Separations Group, Inc., Hesperia, Calif.), with methanol-H2O-H3PO4 (87%), 70:30:0.1, as the mobile phase and a flow rate of 1 ml/min. Excitation was at 333 nm, with detection at 418 nm. Peak areas were calculated from a standard curve based on concentrations from 0.005 to 15 µg/ml of an ochratoxin A standard (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, Mo.). Each isolate was grown at least once in PDB and once in YES. Isolates that produced detectable levels of ochratoxins were tested again for confirmation. The limit of detection for ochratoxin A was 10 ng/ml. Ochratoxin analysis of figs was as previously described (10).
To compare ochratoxin production on grain with that in liquid culture, a subset of 10 isolates, including both ochratoxin producers and nonproducers, was chosen. Twenty grams of hard red winter wheat was soaked in 25 ml of water overnight in 125-ml Erlenmeyer flasks, autoclaved for 1 h, and inoculated. Flasks were incubated at 30°C for 10 days; at 3 days, flasks were shaken to redistribute inoculum. To extract ochratoxin A, the contents of each flask were ground in a blender for 1 min with 72 ml of acetonitrile-water (60:40) and filtered. The acetonitrile was removed in a rotary evaporator, and water was added to 30 ml. The extract was partitioned with 30 ml of chloroform, the chloroform was evaporated, and the extract was resuspended in 1 ml of methanol. Wheat extractions were done in triplicate. Detection and detection limits were as described above.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Ochratoxin A production by Aspergillus isolates in two liquid media
|
The six isolates of A. alliaceus from figs produced ochratoxin A at 2.5 to 6.5 µg/ml in PDA (x = 4.2) and 3.1 to 30 µg/ml in YES (x = 11.0) (Table 1); one (isolate 791) was tested on wheat and produced 13 µg/g. The type isolate of A. alliaceus (NRRL 4181, from Australian soil) did not produce ochratoxin A, and NRRL 315 produced 2.5 µg/ml in PDB and 8.9 µg/ml in YES. A. elegans and A. sclerotiorum isolates from California did not produce ochratoxin A above the limit of detection.
Differences among culture media.
Ochratoxin A production was almost always higher in YES than in PDB. Morphologies were very different in the two media: in PDB most isolates produced a flat mycelium at the surface of the liquid and produced sclerotia, whereas in YES most isolates produced a very thick, deeply furrowed mycelium and fewer sclerotia.
Since higher ochratoxin production has been reported on wheat and corn than in liquid media (4, 13) and since wheat is a natural substrate for ochratoxin production (17, 20), we tested 10 isolates for ochratoxin production on autoclaved wheat. Isolates that did not produce ochratoxins at the level of detection in liquid media did not produce detectable levels of ochratoxins on wheat. Isolates that produced ochratoxins in liquid media also produced them on wheat, at comparable levels. The correlation between ochratoxin production on wheat and production in liquid media (average of PDA and YES values) was highly significant (r2 = 0.99).
Fungi and ochratoxin A in figs.
Among the 50,000 figs collected between 1997 and 1999, figs containing sporulating colonies of potentially ochratoxigenic fungi were rare (Table 2). Penicillium was more common on figs than the A. ochraceus group and A. alliaceus for all 3 years. Aspergillus alliaceus was found in three orchards in 1997 and two orchards in 1999 but was not found in 1998 (Table 2). Pooled sample of figs with Penicillium colonies did not contain ochratoxin A. Samples of figs with colonies of A. alliaceus contained from 0.37 to 7.86 µg of ochratoxin A per g, respectively. Of the samples of figs with the A. ochraceus group, eight contained no detectable ochratoxin A and the remaining samples contained <0.01 µg/g. No ochratoxin A was detected in the seven samples infected with A. ochraceus from 1998, the year in which no A. alliaceus was found.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Ochratoxin A content of figs with colonies of Aspergillus and Penicilliuma
|
|
|
|---|
A. ochraceus group.
Both A. ochraceus and A. melleus have been found in figs, pistachios, and pistachio tree litter in California, at frequencies comparable to those of A. flavus (8, 9, 10). Ochratoxins were first isolated from A. ochraceus, and A. ochraceus has been used as a model system to study ochratoxin production (16, 23, 25, 27, 29). It was therefore surprising that none of the A. ochraceus isolates that we collected produced ochratoxin A above the 0.01-µg/ml limit of detection (Table 1).
While Aspergillus ochraceus strains clearly vary in ochratoxin production (1, 13, 23, 25, 26), comparing results among studies is difficult. For example, some early studies had high limits of detection for ochratoxins (e.g., 100 ng/ml [13]), so some ochratoxin-producing strains may have been missed. In other cases, isolates were tested by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, and only the presence or absence of ochratoxin A was reported (26). Also, early studies used solid media such as corn or wheat (4, 13, 29), whereas recent studies usually used liquid media (1, 19, 24, 26). The highest levels of ochratoxin A have been reported on grain (13), but there is considerable variation in results among different studies testing the same isolates on grain (4, 13). The relatively low ochratoxin A production that we observed in strains ATCC 22947 and NRRL 4181 may reflect a decline of ochratoxin production during decades of maintenance in culture.
Studies of the A. ochraceus group are complicated by difficulties in distinguishing A. ochraceus from related species. Phylogenetic studies based on internal transcribed spacer sequences (28) and large-subunit rDNA sequences (18) both showed A. ochraceus to be poorly delimited. In another study (27), two A. ochraceus clades were identified. All of the members of one clade produced no ochratoxin A, while the other clade included both ochratoxin producers and nonproducers. We hypothesize that most A. ochraceus strains in California belong to the first clade or to a similar group.
We likewise expected some isolates of A. melleus to produce detectable amounts of ochratoxin A. As with A. ochraceus, problems with identification of fungi and delimitation of species may explain part of this inconsistency. However, it appears that populations of A. melleus associated with tree nuts and figs in California are less ochratoxigenic than the A. melleus isolates tested previously.
A. alliaceus.
Unlike A. ochraceus and A. melleus, all A. alliaceus isolates that we tested (except the type isolate) produced ochratoxin A, at concentrations up to 30 µg/ml (Table 1). In three previous studies, one of five isolates, two of two isolates, and six of seven isolates of A. alliaceus produced ochratoxin A (4, 13, 28). A. alliaceus is considered to be widely distributed but not common (15, 21). It has never been identified as a contributor to ochratoxin contamination of crops. A. alliaceus is rare in figs and tree nuts: it was isolated from <0.008% of figs and <0.1% of pistachios in California (8, 10).
Implications for agriculture.
Since the common species A. ochraceus and A. melleus appear to produce little or no ochratoxin A in California, and the only species known to produce high levels of ochratoxin A in California is the relatively rare A. alliaceus, we would predict very low levels of ochratoxin contamination of crops. However, ochratoxin production by the A. niger group in North America has not been studied, and these fungi may also produce ochratoxins (1, 20).
Differences in toxigenicity and distribution of A. alliaceus and Aspergillus section Circumdati may be analogous to those of the aflatoxin-producing aspergilli. Almost all A. parasiticus isolates produce aflatoxins (like A. alliaceus), whereas many A. flavus isolates are atoxigenic or produce very low levels (like A. ochraceus and A. melleus). However, A. parasiticus is much less common than A. flavus in most crops (6). Atoxigenic isolates of A. flavus are being used successfully for biocontrol of aflatoxin contamination of crops; the introduced atoxigenic isolates displace toxigenic ones, making natural populations less toxigenic (6, 7). Fortunately, in the case of ochratoxins in California crops, nonproducing (or very weakly producing) strains already appear to dominate populations of Aspergillus section Circumdati. Since much is known about aflatoxin contamination of crops, and since A. alliaceus has recently been shown to be related to section Flavi (18, 28), knowledge about aflatoxin contamination may be useful for predicting and preventing ochratoxin contamination as well.
In summary, none of our isolates of A. ochraceus or A. melleus produced ochratoxin A at the limit of detection, but all isolates of A. alliaceus produced it, sometimes at high levels. The presence of A. alliaceus was correlated with the presence of ochratoxin A in figs, whereas the presence of the A. ochraceus group and Penicillium was not. Based on our results, future studies of ochratoxin production and contamination by the aspergilli should focus on A. alliaceus rather than A. ochraceus.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»