Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, February 2005, p. 1025-1034, Vol. 71, No. 2
0099-2240/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/AEM.71.2.1025-1034.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
and
Ulrike Gerischer1*
Microbiology and Biotechnology, University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany1
Received 17 June 2004/ Accepted 12 September 2004
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (21K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Catabolic reactions catalyzed by the pca and qui gene products (arrows with filled arrowheads). The biosynthetic reactions of the pathway leading to the formation of the aromatic amino acids are shown with arrows with empty arrowheads. QuiA, quinate/shikimate dehydrogenase; QuiB, dehydroquinate dehydratase; QuiC, dehydroshikimate dehydratase.
|
![]() View larger version (17K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. pca-qui gene region of Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1. Black bars underneath the scheme represent hybridization probes. The results of the Northern blot experiments are summarized in the lower part of the figure. Arrows represent the largest transcripts detected with the probes indicated. Dotted lines show the possible locations of transcripts if they are ambiguous. The locations of the transcripts in this figure were determined (i) by the limits of the gene cluster (pcaI through quiA) and (ii) by the need to overlap the hybridization probes. Transcripts detected in both strain ADP1 and strain ADPU1 ( pcaIp) are shown with thick, dotted lines, and the respective sizes are circled.
|
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Bacterial strains and plasmids used for this study
|
Introduction of plasmids into Acinetobacter.
Plasmids were introduced into Acinetobacter by conjugation from Escherichia coli S17-1 by a procedure similar to that described above for transformation. Overnight cultures of donor and recipient were washed with mineral medium without a carbon source, mixed at a ratio of 1:4, and placed on the membrane. After conjugation, selection pressure was applied for resistance to appropriate antibiotics on a plate with mineral medium for Acinetobacter, which did not allow the growth of E. coli (33).
Strain and plasmid construction.
For the construction of strain ADPU1, plasmid pAC25 was made by deleting a 220-bp SwaI-Eco47III fragment from plasmid pZR18, which contained the structural pca gene promoter pcaIp (Fig. 3). The insert was separated from the vector by digestion with BamHI and HindIII and was used to transform Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1. The transformation mix was plated on a nonselective plate (succinate mineral medium), and colonies were picked on p-hydroxybenzoate mineral medium. Lack of growth on this medium indicated candidates for the respective strain (1 in 400), and the correct establishment of the 220-bp deletion was confirmed by (i) transformation with plasmid pZR18 to reestablish the wild-type phenotype (growth on p-hydroxybenzoate mineral medium) and (ii) PCR of the total DNA of the new strain by the use of primers AC7/4 (GAATAGATCAGTGATGTTTGGG) and AC7/U2 (TTTACCTTCTGCGAGTAAAGTG). Transferring the pcaH19 mutation from strain ADP6417 and the recA100::Tn5 mutation from plasmid pZR106 into strain ADP1 created strain ADPU7 as follows. A PCR with oligonucleotides primer9735 (ACGTGACCAGTTTGGTCGAC) and primer10979 (CATCAACAACGCACCACTTAG) amplified the chromosomal region containing pcaH19, and the resulting fragment was used to transform strain ADP1. The colonies from a nonselective plate were screened for the loss of the capability to grow on p-hydroxybenzoate. Strain ADPU2 was verified by (i) transformation back to the wild-type phenotype with a PCR fragment made from the wild type and (ii) PCR with the primers specified above for the creation of strain ADPU2. Subsequently, the recA gene of this strain was disrupted by transforming it with the EcoRI insert of plasmid pZR106, which contained a Tn5 insertion in the recA gene. Selection for kanamycin resistance allowed the identification of strain ADPU7. The inactivation of recA was necessary to allow the stable establishment of plasmids containing homologous DNAs. Strain ADPU18 was created from strain ADP500 by applying positive selection for the loss of protocatechuate 3,4-dioxygenase as described earlier (14). Mutants were screened for large deletions of the pca-qui-pob region as described previously. To confirm the deletion, we analyzed strain ADPU18 by Southern blot hybridization with (i) the 2,797-bp insert of plasmid pZR17 containing pcaU and (ii) a 1,523-bp XhoI-SacI fragment from plasmid pZR404 containing pobA. Neither of the two probes resulted in the detection of fragments in the DNA of the newly created strain ADPU18, whereas a control with chromosomal DNA from the wild type led to the detection of the expected fragments. Thus, strain ADPU18 contains a deletion of the complete pca-qui-pob area. The endpoints of the deletion have not been defined.
![]() View larger version (14K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Construction of Acinetobacter sp. strain ADPU1 with a deletion of promoter pcaIp. The small horizontal arrows indicate the three sequence repetitions of the PcaU binding site.
|
![]() View larger version (17K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Reporter gene constructs to screen for promoter activity in the pcaG-quiB region and the quiX-quiA region.
|
The probes used for hybridization were DNA restriction fragments prepared as follows. A 552-bp NcoI-MluI fragment from plasmid pZR18 (pcaU), a 640-bp Eco47III fragment from plasmid pZR9 (pcaI), a 397-bp NsiI fragment from plasmid pZR2 (pcaC and -H), a 1,522-bp NsiI fragment from plasmid pZR504 (quiC and -X), and a 442-bp HpaI fragment from plasmid pZR504 (quiA) were isolated by horizontal agarose gel electrophoresis followed by gel extraction by the use of Nucleo Trap (Machery-Nagel, Düren, Germany). The fragments were used as templates to prepare radioactive probes with a random primer DNA labeling system (Life Technologies). Separation from unincorporated nucleotides was done by the use of MicroSpin G-25 columns (Amersham Biosciences). Hybridization was performed as described earlier (13). To ensure that equal amounts of total RNA were used in each lane, we rehybridized each membrane to a 16S rRNA probe after the signal of the first hybridization had decayed for at least 5 months. The probe (731 bp) was generated by whole-cell PCR with cells of Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1 by the use of primers 16SrRNA2 (AGCTGACGACAGCCATGC) and 16SrRNA1 (GTCTGAGAGGATGATCCG). Quantification of the resulting 16S rRNA band revealed a good agreement of the relative abundance of this stable RNA with the amount of total RNA applied to the lanes, based on determinations of the absorbance at 260 nm (the deviation was not higher than 10%). For signal detection, a Fujix BAS 1000 bioimager (Fuji Photo Film Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) was used. Quantitative analysis was done with MacBAS software (Fuji Photo Film Co., Ltd.).
Reverse transcriptase PCR.
Total RNAs were isolated as described above. Reverse transcriptase reactions were performed with Ready-To-Go RT-PCR beads (Amersham Biosciences) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The primers were primer9735 (ACGTGACCAGTTTGGTCGAC) and primer10979 (CATCAACAACGCACCACTTAG) for the pcaG-quiB intergenic region (resulting in a 1,244-bp fragment including the last 472 bp of pcaH and the first 9 bp of quiA) and quiX-14542 (CTATCAATGGTCTCCAG) and quiA-15580 (TTTCCAGAGTCTGCATC) for the quiX-quiA intergenic region (resulting in a 1,038-bp fragment including the last 121 bp of quiX and the first 713 bp of quiA). Controls for the absence of DNA in the RNA preparations were always included by performing a PCR with the RNA.
Primer extension analysis.
A primer extension procedure that was described earlier was applied, with the modification that the primer (quiA-14844 [GTGAGACTTTTCTTGAGGG]) contained a fluorescent label (IRD800) and was purchased from MWG Biotech (Ebersberg, Germany). The sequencing reaction serving as a size standard was produced with the same oligonucleotide and the template pZR504 by use of a SequiTherm EXEL II LC DNA sequencing kit (Epicentre, Madison, Wis.). An automated sequencer (LI-COR 4000L; MWG Biotech) was used for gel separation and data collection.
Determination of ß-galactosidase activity.
The protocol described by Miller was used for determinations of ß-galactosidase activity (27). Cells were permeabilized with chloroform and sodium dodecyl sulfate. The standard deviation for replicate assays from the same sample was no more than 2%. The standard deviations between different cultures (same strain and same conditions) were up to 15%.
|
|
|---|
Promoter search upstream of quiB and of quiA.
The two intergenic regions, pcaG-quiB and quiX-quiA, that were investigated for transcriptional readthrough as described above were analyzed for promoter activity. For this analysis, the respective fragments were cloned upstream of promoterless lacZ cassettes encoding ß-galactosidase, with the shuttle plasmid pRK415 as a vector (Fig. 4). After the introduction of the plasmids into Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP197, the determination of ß-galactosidase activity allowed the identification of promoter activity on the cloned DNAs (Table 2). The area covering the pcaG-quiB intergenic region had no detectable reporter gene activity. In contrast, a 2,318-bp fragment containing quiX and quiA displayed significant ß-galactosidase activity under inducing (growth in the presence of p-hydroxybenzoate and quinate) as well as noninducing (growth in the presence of succinate) conditions, indicating the presence of promoter activity on this fragment. The activity was slightly higher (1.6-fold) than the activity of the structural gene promoter pcaIp under noninducing conditions measured in the same system (plasmid pAC17) (Table 2). To decrease the size of the analyzed fragment, we cloned an 814-bp fragment, resulting in a 3.5-fold higher ß-galactosidase activity than the pcaIp-directed activity without induction (plasmid pAC43) (data not shown). Thus, we found that the region upstream of quiB does not contain any promoter activity, whereas in the area upstream of quiA (narrowed down to an 814-bp region), there is a moderate promoter activity which does not respond to protocatechuate (the inducer of pcaIp), as shown by the use of quinate as a carbon source (which is metabolized via protocatechuate). Furthermore, the introduction of pAC27 into a strain of Acinetobacter with a dysfunctional protocatechuate 3,4-dioxygenase (strain ADPU7) revealed similar ß-galactosidase activities. A promoter dependent on protocatechuate was highly induced under these conditions, as observed for pcaIp (unpublished results), due to the accumulation of protocatechuate in this strain in the absence of an aromatic growth substrate. This internal inducer accumulation has been explained by an overlap of quinate catabolism and the biosynthetic pathway for the aromatic amino acids (Fig. 1) (40). Dehydroshikimate, an intermediate of both pathways, is converted into protocatechuate by the action of QuiC. This is obvious only in the absence of protocatechuate dioxygenase, which in the wild type channels the intermediate into the catabolic pathway (6). Finally, an analysis of pAC27 in strain ADPU331, which contains a dysfunctional PcaU protein (the transcriptional regulator of the pca genes), revealed an activity similar to that in ADP197 (data not shown). The promoter activity upstream of quiA is therefore independent of protocatechuate as well as of PcaU and is probably constitutive.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. ß-Galactosidase activity directed by fragments of the pca-qui gene region
|
![]() View larger version (38K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Primer extension analysis upstream of quiA. Results are shown for an experiment performed with primer quiA-14844 and 10 µg of total RNA from Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1 grown on quinate (lanes 1 and 2) or succinate (lane 3); the sequence ladder was created by using the same primer. The position of the 5' end of the transcript is labeled +1 in the sequence, which was converted to the complementary strand (A). (B) Area upstream of quiA. Two palindromic sequence repetitions upstream of the determined 5' end of the quiA transcript are indicated by horizontal arrows. A potential promoter sequence is indicated and compared with the consensus E. coli promoter sequence.
|
pca qui pob control strain, we consider this signal specific. Its appearance was different from the dark surrounding of the rRNA encountered in cases in which RNA molecules targeted by the probe were pushed away from the far more abundant rRNA (compare with Fig. 7, lane 1, probed with pcaI). It corresponded closely to the size of the quiA gene (2,397 bp). In summary, it can be concluded from these experiments that there is uninterrupted transcription of the pcaIJFBDKCHG and quiBCX genes that is detectable with one of the probes. Smaller transcripts may be primary transcripts or processing products.
![]() View larger version (87K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Transcripts from Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1 detected with a quiX DNA probe by Northern blot analysis of total RNA (10 µg per lane). (A) Growth curve of culture in mineral medium with 20 mM pyruvate. The arrow indicates the addition of the inducer (2 mM protocatechuate). (B) Results of hybridization. Lane numbers correspond to sample numbers, and transcript sizes are given in kilobases. Arrows with empty arrowheads indicate the positions of the 16S and 23S rRNA.
|
![]() View larger version (25K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. Northern blot analysis of the pca-qui gene area. Samples were withdrawn during exponential growth from cultures grown in mineral medium with pyruvate 15 min after the addition of the inducer (2 mM protocatechuate) and were hybridized with the indicated probes. Results are shown for analyses of Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1 (wild type) (A) and strain ADPU1 ( pcaIp) (B) All samples for each strain were taken from the same culture. The appearance of the signal was adjusted (for brightness and contrast) for the best recognition of the bands and does not represent quantitative relationships. Transcript sizes are given in kilobases. Arrows with empty arrowheads indicate the positions of the 16S and 23S rRNA.
|
We compared signal intensities between the wild type and the pcaIp deletion strain. For this comparison, the wild type and the mutant were blotted onto the same membrane and hybridized in the same solution. Subsequent hybridization with a 16S rRNA probe and quantification of the signal ensured that constant levels of RNA were analyzed. The total signal in the lane, corrected for the background, was counted. For each culture, the probe with the highest transcript level was used. When we applied the quiX probe, the mutant had 6% of the wild-type signal. With the quiA probe, the mutant expressed 25% of the wild-type level. Based on this quantitative analysis and on the observation of transcriptional readthrough between quiX and quiA (described above), it can be postulated that the pcaIp promoter is the main promoter for the complete 14-kbp pca-qui gene region. According to this analysis, most of the quiA transcripts (75%) were initiated from this promoter. pcaIp-independent transcriptional activity at two promoters, one of which was the newly described promoter upstream of quiA, contributed significantly to the total transcript abundance covering this area (25%). Considering the fact that the quiA promoter is comparatively weak (1.5% of the activity of fully induced pcaIp), it may reach the high level of 25% due to increased transcript stability.
Transcription of pca and qui genes in the absence of the regulator PcaU.
PcaU governs the expression of the pca genes (15, 37). Deletion of the pcaU gene leads to (i) independence of the inducer protocatechuate and (ii) an increased (threefold) basal level of expression. The effect of PcaU on the expression of the qui genes has not been investigated previously. In contrast, the role of protocatechuate as an inducer of the enzymes for quinate and shikimate catabolism has long been established (39). Since both the pca genes and the qui genes are induced by protocatechuate, it is likely that both are regulated by PcaU. Furthermore, their location on the chromosome would allow their combined transcription and regulation. Evidence for a large primary transcript covering both gene regions was presented above. We next analyzed the consequence of a deletion of the pcaU gene on transcript formation in the pca-qui gene cluster. Therefore, strain ADP331, containing a deletion of two-thirds of the pcaU gene, was used in Northern blot experiments as described above for the wild type. The appearance of transcripts after hybridization with the quiX and quiA probes was the same as that shown for the wild type in Fig. 7, with the difference that the mRNAs were much less abundant and were present at all stages of growth independent of the presence of an inducer (data not shown). With the pcaC and pcaH probe, the transcript was present at a level of 8% that of the induced wild type. This relatively high measurement is consistent with previously described observations, namely, the repressor function of PcaU (37). Using the quiX probe, we obtained slightly increased RNA levels in strain ADP331 (14% of the induced wild-type level). The increase compared to the result obtained with the pcaC and pcaH probe can be explained by the low-level pcaIp-independent transcriptional initiation of pcaG and quiC described above. The use of the quiA probe for strain ADP331 resulted in a transcript level of 25% of the induced wild-type level, which was comparable to the data obtained with the pcaIp-negative strain. This finding supports the presence of a constitutive promoter upstream of quiA.
|
|
|---|
Northern blot analysis with a probe for the first of the pca genes, pcaI, revealed the existence of a transcript of approximately 12 kb. This corresponds to a transcript covering the area between the pcaU-pcaI regulatory region and quiX (Fig. 2). A quantitative comparison of the Northern blots of the
pcaIp strain and the wild type indicated the presence of a full-length transcript including quiA. This potential pca-qui primary transcript has not been detected, most likely because of the extraordinary length of the transcript (14.4 kb) and its short lifetime. We did not measure transcript half-lives for this study, but it is obvious from our Northern blot experiments that the transcript is degraded quickly after the aromatic carbon source is used up (Fig. 6). Several distinct, smaller transcript bands which cannot be exactly located within the pca-qui area and which are probably processing products became visible with the pcaI probe as well as with the other probes (quiX and quiA), as deduced from the fact that most of these transcript bands were not present when we performed the same analysis with the
pcaIp strain. The only exceptions were two transcripts located within the qui genes, namely, a 4-kb transcript found with the quiX and quiA probes and a 2.4-kb transcript detected only with the quiA probe. These two transcripts are present both in the wild type and in the
pcaIp strain and must therefore have a promoter other than pcaIp. The weak 4-kb transcript must have a promoter between pcaG and quiC. The 2.4-kb transcript likely represents a transcript of the quiA gene (2,397 bp). This assumption is based on (i) the promoter activity found upstream of quiA, (ii) the observation of a 5' end of a transcript directly upstream of quiA, and (iii) the fact that it was not detected with the quiX probe in strain ADPU1. Considering the comparatively low activity of the quiA promoter, the low identity with the E. coli
70 consensus promoter sequence makes sense. Promoters with a low activity generally have a recognition sequence that does not show a high similarity to the consensus sequence. The inverted sequence repetitions found upstream of this transcriptional start site may be stabilizing structures of the 12-kb transcript ending behind quiX (32). The newly described quiA promoter was found to be independent from the carbon source tested and therefore constitutive. This is in agreement with earlier data showing that the regulator of the pca genes, PcaU, does not bind to the DNA area upstream of quiA (unpublished observation).
A determination of the transcript abundance indicated that most of the transcripts formed under inducing conditions with the quiA probe (75%) are initiated at pcaIp. This observation further supports this promoter as the main promoter directing both the expression of the pca genes and that of the qui genes, forming a large 14-kbp primary transcript. At least two additional promoters within the qui genes contribute a small part of the overall transcript. Of these two, the newly identified quiA promoter makes the most contribution. It has a low activity which is in the range of the main promoter pcaIp without induction, but the observed quiA transcript is abundant and amounts to 25% of the total quiA transcript. This may be explained by a longer half-life of the quiA transcript.
Having described this situation, we were faced with the question of determining the need for this additional promoter. It is tempting to speculate that the independent quiA transcript is made to ensure a minimal level of the encoded enzyme, quinate dehydrogenase. The enzyme oxidizes both quinate and shikimate, to 5-dehydroquinate and 5-dehydroshikimate, respectively, by using pyrrolo-quinoline quinone as a cofactor (Fig. 1) (41). It feeds the electrons into the electron transport chain. For Acinetobacter calcoaceticus L.M.D. 79.41, cytochrome b-562 was shown to be the electron acceptor (9). The generated proton motive force allows a considerable contribution to the energy conservation of the cell or can be used for secondary transport processes such as the uptake of the aromatic substrates protocatechuate and p-hydroxybenzoate by PcaK and VanK, members of the major facilitator superfamily (8, 28, 41). Protocatechuate is the product of the sequential reaction of quinate dehydrogenase (QuiA), 5-dehydroquinate dehydratase (QuiB), and 5-dehydroshikimate dehydratase (QuiC). There is strong evidence that these reactions all take place in the periplasm and that the carbon source is then transported into the cell by PcaK and VanK, supported by the energy from quinate oxidation (8). This possibility is supported by the finding of a membrane association of quinate dehydrogenase and a potential leader sequence (39 amino acid residues) in the QuiB N terminus (1, 11). A constitutive level of the enzyme would ensure that these reactions can take place even before the inducer of both gene clusters, protocatechuate, can enter the cell.
Insights into the way that the qui genes are expressed are also relevant because the genes are induced by the product of the encoded pathway (and not by the substrate). Thus, a minimal level of the Qui proteins must be present even under noninducing conditions to allow the formation of the inducer molecule, a situation reminiscent of the induction process of the lac operon in E. coli. The expression of the pca genes has been shown to take place at a comparatively high level under noninducing conditions (37). Having established the transcript structure of the pca-qui operon as one large transcript, it can now be assumed that the basal level of qui gene expression is comparable to that of pca gene expression (assuming that the processing of the primary transcript does not cause strong imbalances in terms of transcript level between the 5'-located genes and the 3'-located genes). This basal level of pca-qui operon expression should be sufficient to allow efficient induction of the operon upon confrontation of the cells with quinate or shikimate. In addition, according to the finding that the Qui proteins are active in the periplasm, the transport of protocatechuate into the cell is required, and this activity is accomplished by PcaK and VanK. The pcaK gene, being part of the pca gene cluster (upstream of the qui genes), is likely to underlie the same expression pattern discussed above. The expression of vank is unknown.
Another aspect comes into play in the context discussed here. It is the old observation that strains of Acinetobacter with a dysfunctional protocatechuate-3,4-dioxygenase (PcaH and -G) show maximal induction of the pca and qui genes (6, 39). The generally accepted explanation for this phenomenon was that dehydroshikimate formed by enzymes of the biosynthetic pathway for the formation of the three aromatic amino acids is partially converted to protocatechuate. In the absence of the dioxygenase, protocatechuate accumulates to levels that are high enough to cause induction. The necessary precondition for this to happen is, again, a certain basal level of expression of the qui genes, which can now be understood as explained above. In addition, this scenario directs attention to a situation in which a catabolic pathway (the quinate degradative reactions) and an essential anabolic pathway (the biosynthetic reactions for the family of aromatic amino acids) potentially compete for a common intermediate (dehydroshikimate). It is unknown how the organism deals with this seemingly serious conflict. Aspergillus nidulans, being confronted with a similar situation, forms a biosynthetic multienzyme complex which channels the anabolic intermediates under physiologically significant conditions (26). In Acinetobacter, the location of the Qui proteins outside of the cytoplasm certainly presents a solution for the organism in terms of the potential pathway conflict described. On the other hand, the observation that a quiB deletion mutant grows (albeit extremely slowly) on quinate indicates that the catabolic and the biosynthetic pathways are not completely separated in this bacterium (11). The cytoplasmic biosynthetic dehydroquinate dehydratase (AroD) must complement the missing QuiB, the catabolic enzyme with identical activity. A complete physical separation also does not agree with the endogenous induction of the pca-qui operon. There are three possible explanations for this new situation: (i) there is a different source of protocatechuate besides the biosynthetic dehydroshikimate pool, (ii) other intermediates besides protocatechuate can cause PcaU-mediated induction, or (iii) the QuiC protein is not completely excreted into the membrane or periplasm but remains in the cytoplasm to some extent. Thus, our insights into the complex network of factors contributing to the control of gene expression of the newly established pca-qui operon have been extended, but the system still awaits experimental investigation for all of its details to be understood.
The excellent technical assistance of Iris Steiner is appreciated.
Present address: Ratiopharm GmbH, 89079 Ulm, Germany. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»