Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, December 2006, p. 7829-7834, Vol. 72, No. 12
0099-2240/06/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/AEM.01207-06
Copyright © 2006, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Biology, University of New Brunswick, P.O. Bag Service 45111, Fredericton E3B 6E1, New Brunswick, Canada,1 Department of Biological Oceanography, Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, P.O. Box 59, Den Burg NL-1790 AB, The Netherlands,2 Departments of Earth and Ocean Sciences, Botany, and Microbiology & Immunology, University of British Columbia, 6270 University Blvd., Vancouver V6T 1Z4, British Columbia, Canada3
Received 24 May 2006/ Accepted 5 October 2006
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Viral infections of phytoplankton populations can be difficult to detect. TEM analysis is labor-intensive and time-consuming and has very high limits of detection, as cells have to be individually examined for ultrastructural changes associated with infection. Molecular detection of infection requires the development of specific probes targeted to known viruses or groups of related viruses. Flow cytometry (FCM) has been used to detect viral infection of phytoplankton (6) and has been used to study infections of Phaeocystis pouchetii and Micromonas pusilla by two dsDNA viruses (5). FCM permits rapid and precise cell-by-cell analysis of phytoplankton in which light scattering and fluorescence are measured simultaneously. FCM in combination with fluorescent live/dead stains allows the detection of mortality due to viral infection in phytoplankton (5) by revealing changes in cellular physiology associated with cell death.
The current study uses FCM to compare the lytic cycles of two viruses, HaRNAV and OIs1, and the progression of cell death in H. akashiwo. HaRNAV was isolated from the Strait of Georgia, British Columbia, Canada. This ssRNA virus belongs to the Marnaviridae, has a genome of 9.1 kb and a particle diameter of 25 nm, and is assembled in the cytoplasm (17, 34). OIs1 is a partially characterized dsDNA virus isolated from the sediment of Malaspina Inlet, British Columbia, Canada (20). There are two cooccurring icosahedral morphotypes, differing in particle size (30 versus 80 nm) and genome size (20 kb versus 130 kb), which assemble in the cytoplasm of their host (J. Lawrence, unpublished data). In this system, both morphotypes are visible in an infected host at the same time. By comparing infections with these two viruses, we demonstrate that the characteristics of viral infection are virus dependent.
|
|
|---|
Exponentially growing cultures of H. akashiwo (600 ml) were inoculated with 1% (vol/vol) HaRNAV or OIs1 in duplicate. Noninfected cultures served as a control. Samples for in vivo fluorescence and FCM were taken every 6 h for 59 h, after which a final sample was taken at 71 h for those cultures that still contained live cells.
Analyses.
Algal cell counts and two viability assays were performed immediately after sampling on unfixed material by use of a FACSCalibur flow cytometer (Becton Dickinson, San Jose, CA) equipped with a 15-mW, 488-nm, air-cooled argon ion laser and a standard filter setup (5, 21). The trigger was set on red autofluorescence, and samples were run for 1 min at a delivery rate of 150 µl min1. Sheath fluid for both assays consisted of filtered seawater (0.2-µm-pore-size filter). Sphero Nile Red high-intensity particles (1.7 to 2.2 µm; Becton Dickinson, San Jose, CA) were added as an internal reference to all algal samples. Fluorescence data were normalized to the bead internal standard. Chl a autofluorescence per cell was examined using FCM. A window (window A) was set around cells with relatively high red autofluorescence in the control culture (t = 0) (ca. 100% of the cells), and cells within this window were analyzed.
Metabolically active ("live") cells were detected using the dye fluorescein diacetate (FDA) (Sigma-Aldrich), which readily diffuses into cells and becomes fluorescent upon hydrolysis by intracellular esterases (16). FDA was used instead of calcein-AM (5), as the latter gave unsatisfactory results with H. akashiwo. Prior to experiments, the FDA assay was optimized for dye concentration and incubation time. Cells were stained with FDA to a final concentration of 2 nM FDA (using a 2 mM working stock of FDA in pure acetone stored at 20°C) and incubated in the dark at in situ temperature (20°C) for 30 min. Incubations of 20 to 40 min gave optimal green fluorescence of live cells without significant increases in signal from fixed dead cells. No difference was observed for incubations in the dark or in situ light. Figure 1A shows a typical example of live and dead subpopulations of virally infected H. akashiwo cells after staining with FDA.
![]() View larger version (25K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Representative biparametric plots of green fluorescence versus chlorophyll red autofluorescence of virally infected cultures of H. akashiwo after staining with green fluorescent live/dead stains (A) FDA and (B) SYTOX green. r.u., relative units.
|
Viruses and bacteria were enumerated with FCM using SYBR green I stain (Invitrogen) after fixation with glutaraldehyde (0.5% final concentration, EM grade) and freezing in liquid nitrogen according to Brussaard (2). Since tests with other ssRNA viruses done using SYBR green II did not provide better results (4), we used SYBR green I for all analyses. All samples were zeroed with a buffer blank (Tris-EDTA buffer with sterile filtered seawater [0.2-µm-pore-size filter]), and the infected cultures were corrected for background counts using uninfected control cultures. Unfortunately, several virus samples of the HaRNAV-infected cultures were lost prior to analysis.
Flow cytometric parameters were collected as logarithmic signals and analyzed with CYTOWIN (freely available at http://www.sb-roscoff.fr/Phyto/index.php). For analyses of the collected data, the discrimination between various subpopulations was set for an example typical of the uninfected controls and kept constant for all samples.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (14K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Biomass of H. akashiwo cultures measured by (A) in vivo natural fluorescence and (B) cell abundance of cultures infected with either HaRNAV or OIs1 compared to uninfected control cultures. Bars on the x axis indicate the dark periods. Experiments were performed in duplicate; mean values are presented, with standard errors of the means indicated by bars (if not visible, the error is smaller than the symbol). r.u., relative units.
|
![]() View larger version (13K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Cellular characteristics (normalized to fluorescent 1-µm beads) of H. akashiwo cultures as obtained by FCM. Presented are the natural parameters red autofluorescence, forward light scatter, and side-angle light scatter. Bars on the x axis indicate the dark periods. Experiments were performed in duplicate; mean values are presented, with standard errors of the means indicated by bars (if not visible, the error is smaller than the symbol). r.u., relative units.
|
By use of the live/dead stains FDA and SYTOX green, H. akashiwo cells in the uninfected control cultures were found to be in good physiological condition throughout the experiment (Fig. 4). Independent of the type of live/dead stain, the percentage of dead OIs1-infected cells started to increase earlier than did the percentage of HaRNAV-infected cultures (17 to 23 h versus 29 to 35 h) and continued to increase until complete lysis 48 h postinfection. In contrast, the percentage of dead HaRNAV cells leveled off at a maximum of 30% according to the FDA assay. For OIs1-infected cultures, both assays gave comparable data, except that the maximum percentage of dead cells was higher by use of the FDA stain. This was not the case for HaRNAV-infected cultures, where there was a steep increase in the percentage of SYTOX-dead cells 29 h after infection with HaRNAV, although the cells still stained with FDA. Six hours later, however, the percentages of dead HaRNAV-infected cells were equal by use of the FDA and SYTOX green assays.
![]() View larger version (14K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Percentages of dead cells of H. akashiwo cultures infected with either HaRNAV or OIs1 compared to percentages of dead cells of uninfected cultures. Live/dead stains used were FDA and SYTOX green. The percentage of dead cells was obtained directly from the percentage of fluorescently labeled dead cells when using the SYTOX green assay or indirectly as the inverse of the percentage of fluorescently labeled live cells when using the FDA assay. Experiments were performed in duplicate; mean values are presented, with standard errors of the means indicated by bars (if not visible, the error is smaller than the symbol).
|
20 h (Fig. 7).
![]() View larger version (24K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Biparametric dot plots of green fluorescence versus side scatter representing virus systems (A) OIs1 and (B) HaRNAV. Viruses were stained with the nucleic acid-specific green fluorescent dye SYBR green I. The low-green-fluorescence virus population also included bacteriophages. r.u., relative units.
|
![]() View larger version (14K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Flow cytometric enumeration of H. akashiwo virus systems (A) HaV-OIs1 and (B) HaRNAV. The HaNAV-OIs1 system consisted of two virus morphotypes, one with a high green fluorescence and the other with a low green fluorescence after staining with a nucleic acid-specific dye. The HaRNAV system consisted of only one morphotype with a very low green fluorescence. Data were corrected for the blank and the uninfected controls. Experiments were performed in duplicate; mean values are presented, with standard errors of the means indicated by bars (if not visible, the error is smaller than the symbol).
|
![]() View larger version (17K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. Variation in bacterial abundance in H. akashiwo cultures infected with OIs1 or HaRNAV. Data were corrected for the blank and the uninfected controls. Experiments were performed in duplicate; mean values are presented, with standard errors of the means indicated by bars (if not visible, the error is smaller than the symbol).
|
|
|
|---|
OIs1-infected cultures showed initial signs of infection 6 h earlier than HaRNAV-infected cultures (17 versus 23 h) as indicated by in vivo fluorescence and cell abundance and 17 h earlier as indicated by the relative fluorescence levels of individual cells (6 versus 23 h). The results from the live/dead assays supported this finding; the percentage of dead cells increased after 11 to 17 h for OIs1-infected cultures but only after 23 to 29 h for the HaRNAV-infected cultures. This provides us with estimates for the latent periods of 11 to 17 h for OIs1 and 23 to 29 h for HaRNAV.
The live/dead stains provided insight into specific physiological changes occurring during infection. OIs1-infected cells lost intracellular esterase activity (FDA assay) more rapidly than membrane permeability increased (SYTOX green assay), whereas the opposite occurred in HaRNAV-infected cultures. In a previous study, TEM also showed that OIs1 produced viruses earlier than HaRNAV, as only 10% of HaRNAV-infected cells showed visible signs of infection 24 h postinfection, compared to 93% of OIs1-infected cells (18). While the maximum percentage of dead HaRNAV-infected cells was low by either of the live/dead assays, in vivo fluorescence and cell numbers indicated that lysis occurred in most HaRNAV-infected cells. This suggests that dying cells undergo rapid lysis, thus preventing a standing stock of dead cells, as reported previously for Phaeocystis pouchetii (5). In contrast, dead and dying cells infected with OIs1 accumulate in the culture prior to lysis.
In contrast, changes in light scattering were similar in H. akashiwo cultures infected with either OIs1 or HaRNAV. In either case, the light scattering signals were higher in infected cells than in uninfected control cells. Enhanced forward scatter has also been reported previously for infected Micromonas pusilla cells and was related to swelling of the cells (6). However, the scatter increased more and for a longer time in cells infected with OIs1 than in cells infected with HaRNAV, possibly because of the proliferation of the two virus morphotypes.
High (OIs1HI)- and low (OIs1LO)-fluorescence populations of virus-sized particles were observed for OIs1-infected cultures. As the OIs1 virus strain consists of two different morphotypes infecting and replicating inside individual cells at the same time (J. Lawrence, unpublished data), OIs1HI most likely represents the larger-diameter virus with the larger genome size (80 nm and 130 kb), while OIs1LO is likely the smaller virus (30 nm and 20 kb). Although bacteriophages are also included in OIs1LO, this low-fluorescence population grew rapidly after 10 h (Fig. 6A) while there was no change in the bacterial population at this time that could be attributable to phage release (Fig. 7). Additionally, the control cultures contained, at maximum, 6.4 x 105 ml1 viruses throughout the experiment, or about 2% of total virus counts in the infected cultures.
The small-genome ssRNA HaRNAV (8.5 kb) could not be separated from the phages (Fig. 5B), nor did it increase in abundance earlier than the bacteria (Fig. 6B and 7). While we cannot be certain we were detecting HaRNAV, other ssRNA viruses have been stained successfully with fluorescent dyes, such as SYBR green I and II, OliGreen, and PicoGreen (4, 27). Bacteria rapidly accumulate and respond to the products of viral lysis of phytoplankton (7, 10), and the delayed increase in bacterial abundance of HaRNAV-infected cultures was likely due to the delayed lysis of HaRNAV-infected compared to OIs1-infected cultures.
The latent period of OIs1HI was approximately 6 h longer than that of OIs1LO (17 h instead of 11 h) (Fig. 6A). Therefore, the appearance of OIs1LO precedes lysis of the host cell, while release of OIs1HI occurs concomitantly with cellular lysis. The latent period of either particle is noticeably shorter than the 30 to 33 h for HaV, a large dsDNA virus infecting H. akashiwo (26). The latent period of HaRNAV was at least three times longer than that of the OIs1 model system.
Based on the FCM virus counts, we estimate the virus-to-alga host ratio at the start of the experiment for OIs1HI to be
7:1, which should result in near-synchronous infection of the cells. The virus-to-host ratio at the start of the experiment for OIs1LO and HaRNAV could not be determined, because the number of phages introduced with the algal viruses was unknown. From the net production of OIs1HI and net loss of H. akashiwo cells, we estimate that 1,100 large OIs1 particles were produced per cell. In contrast, if most of the low-fluorescence virus population prior to 35 h is attributed to OIs1LO then
16,000 small OIs1 particles were produced per cell. Estimates of viral production for HaRNAV are even less certain, but if most of the particles produced prior to 53 h were HaRNAV, then
21,000 viruses cell1 were produced.
The two virus systems examined in this study were isolated from nearby areas. Their coexistence presents a paradox reminiscent of the paradox of the plankton, referring to species that "coexist in a relatively isotropic or unstructured environment all competing for the same sorts of materials" (15) rather than competitively excluding each other (12). In our case, two unrelated viruses, and likely many others, coexist in the same environment and compete for the same host when we might expect one virus to outcompete the other. Harris' (13) explanation for the paradox of the plankton is that the ocean is not homogeneous. Equilibrium is rarely attained; the frequency and intensity of environmental fluctuations are high enough that competitive exclusion is disrupted (8). The paradox of the viruses can likewise be explained by heterogeneity, but in this case it may be biological variability and the inherent dynamics of phytoplankton blooms that allow two virus systems infecting the same host to coexist. The latent period of OIs1 is shorter than that of HaRNAV. The rapid release of progeny viruses following infection and the subsequent swift propagation of OIs1 infection lend this virus a competitive advantage over HaRNAV when the host density is high. Although the lytic cycle of HaRNAV is longer, HaRNAV also displays high viral production rates. Thus, HaRNAV has an advantage when host density is low. In this manner, latent period and burst size interact with the rapidly fluctuating host densities inherent in phytoplankton blooms and may lead to one virus being temporarily favored over another on short time scales. If this variability is overlaid against complex patterns of host range (28, 29, 32) and decay rates of viral infectivity (9, 33), it seems apparent that the biological variability is great enough to allow the coexistence of viruses infecting the same host.
We are only beginning to appreciate the diversity of viruses that infect marine phytoplankton. As we continue to discover novel algal viruses and gain insight into their biology, we will be able to better comprehend their undoubtedly complex role in shaping marine microbial ecosystems.
Published ahead of print on 13 October 2006. ![]()
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»