Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, July 2006, p. 4839-4844, Vol. 72, No. 7
0099-2240/06/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/AEM.00167-06
Copyright © 2006, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Laboratoire Microbiologie Moléculaire des Actinomycètes, Institut de Génétique et Microbiologie, UMR CNRS 8621, Bât. 400, Université Paris-Sud, F-91405 Orsay, France
Received 23 January 2006/ Accepted 17 April 2006
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
In a previous work, we constructed gene cassettes carrying antibiotic resistance markers that were selectable in both Escherichia coli and Streptomyces. These were used to inactivate genes of interest through insertional mutagenesis (2). These cassettes carry heterologous genes that confer antibiotic resistance. If these markers are widely used to select genetic transformants, they may have an unintended detrimental environmental impact. Besides this concern, there are other reasons for removing and/or recycling selective markers, especially when several modifications are required. If every genetic modification in a given strain results in an antibiotic marker being retained in the modified organism, and if the combination of several mutations needs to be analyzed, it becomes progressively more difficult to find new antibiotic resistance genes to use. Moreover, this situation prevents a plethora of selectable markers from being used in subsequent rounds of gene modification in the same host. Also, the insertion of a resistance cassette into a gene that is part of an operon may have a polar effect on the expression of downstream genes.
This work aimed to set up a system that allows the cassette to be removed, leaving only a short sequence with no polar effect. For the gene to be inactivated under these conditions, the insertion of the cassette must be combined with the deletion of part or all of the gene. After excision, it should be possible to obtain a gene deletion where the original reading frame is maintained. Such a mutation is not expected to be polar.
pSAM2 is an 11-kb integrative element from Streptomyces ambofaciens (15). It possesses a site-specific recombination system very similar to that of temperate phages (3). It also has functions common to Streptomyces plasmids, such as replication, transfer, pock formation, and mobilization of chromosomal markers (24). The repSA, xis, and int genes, which encode the replicase, the excisionase, and the integrase, respectively, are organized as an operon that is activated by the pra gene product (21). The integrase can promote intermolecular recombination between the attachment sites attP and attB, leading to the formation of attL and attR, which flank the integrated sequence. The expression of both int and xis leads to excision via intramolecular recombination between attL and attR. The att sequences required for site-specific recombination have been studied in detail and precisely defined (17, 18). Our work aimed to produce an attL-antibiotic resistance gene-attR cassette that carries blunt end restriction sites at both extremities. This allows easy insertion into the cloned target gene that is to be inactivated. In a second step, this construction can be integrated via a double crossover to replace the wild-type gene with its disrupted counterpart in the Streptomyces genome. The third step consists of removing the cassette via a site-specific excision event promoted by the expression of the xis and int genes in trans. Polar effects were avoided for a disrupted gene belonging to an operon by constructing different cassettes that leave a 33-, 34-, or 35-bp "attB-like" sequence after excision.
|
|
|---|
(8) was used
for cloning experiments and plasmid DNA propagation.
Streptomyces strains were routinely cultivated on
Hickey-Tresner medium at 30°C as described previously
(15). Streptomyces
lividans strain TK24 and Streptomyces ambofaciens ATCC
23877 were used for transformation experiments. Transformants carrying
the hyg, tsr, or aac resistance gene were
selected with 150 to 200 µg hygromycin (Hm)
ml1, 25 µg thiostrepton (Ts)
ml1, or 50 µg geneticin (Gn)
ml1, respectively, in R2YE medium
(10).Transformants harboring the aac gene can also be selected with
apramycin or gentamicin. Streptomyces ambofaciens ATCC 23877
produces the macrolide antibiotic spiramycin
(16). Bacteria containing
plasmids were routinely grown on LB medium supplemented with 100
µg ampicillin (Ap) ml1 and 20 µg Gn
ml1, and bacterial cultures in liquid LB medium
were supplemented with 30 µg Ap ml1 and 10
µg Gn ml1.
Plasmids, antibiotic resistance genes, and oligonucleotides.
All restriction endonuclease
digestions, ligation reactions, DNA modifications, and PCR
amplifications were carried out according to standard protocols
(19). E. coli
and Streptomyces were transformed according to standard
protocols (11,
19). The plasmid pGEM-T
Easy (Promega) was used for cloning of PCR products, and pBluescript
(Stratagene) was used for the cloning experiments. All of the plasmids
used in this study are listed in Table
1. KS+DH3, a pBluescript KS (+) derivative deleted for the
HindIII restriction site, was constructed to clone the antibiotic
resistance genes.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Plasmid
characteristics and
construction
|
hyg and
aac cassettes
(2), respectively, derived
from the
interposon as HindIII-HindIII fragments. A
HindIII fragment containing only the aac gene was obtained by
PCR amplification using the primers KF42
(5'AAGCTTGTACGGCCCACAGAATGATGTCAC3')
and KF43
(5'AAGCTTCGACTACCTTGGTGATCTCGCCTT3')
(HindIII sites are underlined), with an
aac cassette
containing a plasmid as the DNA template. The resulting PCR product was
inserted into pGEM-T Easy. A HindIII fragment carrying the aac
gene was obtained from the resulting plasmid. Initial
attL-attR cassettes were obtained after two
successive PCR steps using the following primers: Cas1R
(5'CATGCCGGTCGGGATATCGCGCGCTTCGTTCG3'),
Cas2R
(5'CATGCCGGTCGGGATATCGGCGCGCTTCGTTCG3'),
Cas3R
(5'CATGCCGGTCGGGATATCGCGCGCGCTTCGTTCG3'),
CasR
(5'AGATCTGTTAACAAGCTTCTCGAGGGATCCCTGTCAGTCATGCGGG3'),
CasL
(5'GGATCCCTCGAGAAGCTTGTTAACAGATCTCCCGGCTCGTCGGAC3'),
Cas1/2L
(5'CCCGGGGATCTGGATATCTACCTCTTCGTCCC3'),
and Cas3L
(5'CCCGGGGATCGTGATATCTGCCTCTTCGTCCC3').
Spiramycin production assays.
For
spiramycin production, S. ambofaciens was grown in MP5 liquid
medium at 27°C
(14). For bioassays, the
supernatant of the culture was applied to Whatman AA paper discs. The
discs were laid on plates containing Micrococcus luteus, and
the plates were first incubated at 4°C for 2 hours to allow
antibiotic diffusion and then incubated at 37°C. The growth
inhibition area was measured and compared to standards obtained using
spiramycin, as described previously
(14).
Construction of S. ambofaciens ATCC 23877 derivative devoid of pSAM2.
Since we were using
the site-specific recombination system from pSAM2 to carry out excision
in S. ambofaciens, we preferred to work with an S.
ambofaciens strain devoid of pSAM2 to avoid all kinds of
interference due to the integrated copy of pSAM2. Therefore,
experiments were undertaken to obtain an S. ambofaciens strain
cured of the integrated copy of pSAM2. It has been reported that the
production and regeneration of bacterial protoplasts can promote the
loss of plasmids (5).
Since the pSAM2 functions are well characterized, we designed a
reporter system allowing positive selection for the loss of
pSAM2.
The pra gene has been described as an activator of pSAM2 replication, and its inactivation leads to the disappearance of free pSAM2 (22). KorSA has been identified as a central transcriptional repressor (23) that binds to the pra gene promoter, thus repressing pra gene expression. The rationale behind this experiment is that derepression of the pra promoter should be observed in the absence of the KorSA repressor, indicating the loss of pSAM2. We used pOS527 to obtain a fragment carrying the pra promoter fused to the promoterless aph gene (22), which was inserted into the unstable replicative vector pWHM3hyg, a pWHM3 (26) derivative in which the tsr gene (conferring Ts resistance) is replaced by hyg (conferring Hm resistance). The resulting plasmid, pOSV510, was used to transform protoplasts of the S. ambofaciens ATCC 23877 strain. Selection with neomycin of clones expressing the aph reporter gene allowed S. ambofaciens strains devoid of pSAM2 to be isolated. The absence of pSAM2 was checked by Southern blotting (data not shown), and one of the obtained clones was named OSC2. The OSC2 strain was not affected in growth, sporulation, or spiramycin production.
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers.
The following sequences
were deposited in the EMBL database with the indicated accession
numbers: att1
aac+,
AM238621;
att2
aac+,
AM238622;
att3
aac+,
AM238623;
att1
hyg+,
AM238624;
att2
hyg+,
AM238625;
att3
hyg+,
AM238626;
att1
aac,
AM238627;
att2
aac,
AM238628;att3
aac,
AM238629;
att1
hyg,
AM238630;
att2
hyg,
AM238631; and
att3
hyg,
AM238632.
|
|
|---|
Construction was undertaken
starting from plasmid pOSCo26, a cointegrate
resulting from site-specific recombination between pSAM2 attP
and the minimal attB26 site
(16). In the first step
(Fig.
1a), attR and attL were amplified as individual
fragments from the cointegrate molecules. The CasR and CasL primers
carried a 30-nucleotide common sequence, with an inverted orientation
in one of the primers. This allowed both to associate with the
attR/attL molecules obtained from the first PCR and
to create restriction sites that allow the antibiotic resistance genes
to be inserted between attR and attL in a further
step. In a second PCR step (Fig.
1a), the PCR products from
the first step were used as templates for amplification, using
different couples of external primers that provided EcoRV restriction
sites. This allowed a set of cassettes to be generated, named CASS1,
CASS2, and CASS3, containing both attR and attL and
having respective sizes of 485, 486, and 487 bp (Fig.
1b). These cassettes were
further inserted as EcoRV-EcoRV fragments into the plasmid
KS+DH3, leading to the plasmids pOSV501, pOSV502, and pOSV503,
respectively. In the next step, an antibiotic resistance cassette was
inserted between the attL and attR sites in these
plasmids (Fig. 1c). Both
hyg and
aac cassettes
(2), carrying Hm and Gn
resistance genes, respectively, were inserted as HindIII fragments into
pOSV501, pOSV502, and pOSV503. Since there were three types of sequence
left after excision (att1, 33 bp; att2, 34 bp; and
att3, 35 bp) (Fig.
1d), two possible
orientations of the marker genes (+ denotes a resistance gene
transcribed in the attL-to-attR orientation, and
denotes a resistance gene transcribed in the other
orientation), and two different fragments carrying the resistance genes
(
hyg and
aac), this led to a set of
12 plasmids containing the cassettes
att1
hyg+/,
att2
hyg+/,
att3
hyg+/,
att1
aac+/,
att2
aac+/, and
att3
aac+/ (Table
1). The derivatives of
plasmid KS+DH3 containing these cassettes are designated by the
letter "p" followed by the name of the
cassette.
![]() View larger version (31K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Construction
and characteristics of excisable cassettes. (a) attL and
attR were amplified individually by PCRs using the CasR and
CasL primer families. (b) The CasL-CasR central primers share a
30-nucleotide inverted repeat sequence that allows attL1,
-2, and -3 to be associated with attR1,
-2, and -3, respectively, followed by PCR
amplification using external CasL and CasR primers carrying an EcoRV
restriction site sequence. The second PCR step generates the cassettes,
CASS1, -2, and -3 (c), carrying a multicloning site in the central
part, allowing antibiotic resistance cassette cloning. (d)
Representation of the 33-, 34-, and 35-bp sequences remaining after
excision, with respect to the reading frame and the cassette cloning
orientation. In att2 and att3, the bold characters
indicate nucleotides coming from the disrupted gene. There are some
constraints in the possible nucleotide that can be used to avoid a stop
codon in the sequence remaining after
excision.
|
Functionality of excision in E. coli and Streptomyces.
The excisable cassettes can be isolated
as blunt-ended EcoRV fragments from the plasmids that carry them and
easily inserted into any gene, as insertion of the cassette can be
selected by the appropriate antibiotic in both E. coli and
Streptomyces. Excision of the cassette can be achieved by
expressing the xis and int genes and can be screened
for by the loss of antibiotic resistance. The signatures left by the
cassettes after excision are shown in Fig.
1d with respect to the
reading frame and the cassette cloning orientation in the disrupted
gene. Some constraints exist for using the cassette that leaves the
att2 or att3 sequence.
We investigated the
excision event by inserting the att1
hyg cassette,
isolated as an EcoRV fragment, into pSET152 digested by EcoRV, yielding
pOSV511. The vector pSET152, which can replicate in E. coli,
carries a Gn resistance marker (Gnr) and the FC31 attachment
site, which allows its integration into the chromosomes of several
Streptomyces species
(1). pOSV511 was
introduced into a strain of E. coli containing pOSint3
(18) and therefore
expressing the int and xis genes. Among the
transformants selected as Gnr colonies, >90% were
Hms, showing very efficient excision of the cassette in
E. coli.
We tested the excision efficiency in
Streptomyces by introducing pOSV511 into S. lividans
strain TK24 by protoplast transformation. Integrative transformants
were selected as Gnr Hmr colonies. Southern
blotting with three different transformants showed that the fragment
containing att1
hyg+ had been integrated into
the S. lividans chromosome.
We introduced the plasmid pOSV507 expressing the xis and int genes from pSAM2 into S. lividans carrying integrated pOSV511 to promote the excision of the cassette (data not shown; see below). The transformants were picked and grown on plates with no Hm selection. After two rounds of sporulation under these conditions, we tested the isolated clones for their Hm resistance. Hms clones were readily obtained. Southern blotting with total DNA extracted from two of these Hms clones confirmed excision of the cassette (data not shown). The regions containing the sequence left after excision were cloned by marker rescue and sequenced; in both cases, we found the expected 33-nucleotide sequences flanked by the two EcoRV cloning sites (data not shown). All of these results clearly showed that the excision of the cassette was efficient in S. lividans as well as in E. coli and was site specific, leaving the expected attB-like sequence after excision.
Example of the use of the cassettes: insertion of a cassette into a target gene.
We showed how these cassettes could be
used by choosing to inactivate a gene belonging to an operon located in
the spiramycin biosynthetic cluster of Streptomyces
ambofaciens. Seven genes, orf1 to orf7, encoding
enzymes involved in various steps of spiramycin biosynthesis form an
operon (N. Oestreicher et al., unpublished). It was shown that
inserting the
hyg cassette into orf3, the
third gene of this operon, abolished spiramycin production. However,
insertion of this cassette caused a polar effect on transcription of
the downstream genes, orf4 to orf7. After several
gene replacement steps, it was possible to obtain an in-frame deletion
in orf3; this deletion still abolished spiramycin biosynthesis
but did not cause a polar effect (N. Oestreicher et al., unpublished).
We repeated the orf3 inactivation, using an excisable cassette
to test whether there was no polar effect after excision.
A
4.5-kb EcoRI-BamHI fragment containing orf1 to orf4
of this operon was inserted into pUC19, yielding pOS49.99. In this
fragment, orf3 was disrupted by inserting the
att1
hyg cassette, isolated as an EcoRV fragment. This
fragment was inserted into pOS49.99 after PmlI/Asp718I digestion,
followed by filling in of the two protruding ends, giving the plasmid
pOSV512. The insertion of the cassette was accompanied by deletion of
270 bp of the orf3 coding sequence. A fragment carrying
orf1-2-orf3::att1
hyg-orf4 was
inserted into pOJ260, a vector unable to replicate in
Streptomyces (1),
leading to pOSV513. This first step is represented schematically in
Fig.
2a.
![]() View larger version (21K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Schematic
representation of the different steps for generating unmarked mutant
strains. (a) Step 1, cloning of the gene of interest, followed by its
disruption by insertion of the chosen cassette. (b) Step 2, replacement
of the wild-type copy of the target gene by the disrupted gene via a
double recombination event. (c) Step 3, excision of the cassette at the
chromosomal locus after transitional expression of Xis and
Int.
|
hyg were
selected for further analysis. Both clones were unable to produce
spiramycin (Fig. 2b and
3b).
![]() View larger version (35K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Representation
of the different structures at the orf1-orf7 operon in
different strains of S. ambofaciens. (a) S.
ambofaciens OSC2, an ATCC 23877 derivative devoid of pSAM2. (b)
Same strain after inactivation of orf3 by insertion of
att1 hyg
(orf3::att1 hyg).
(c) Same strain after excision of the cassette
(orf3::att1). (d) Construct b
with orf3 carried by plasmid pOS49.52. (e) Construct c with
orf3 carried by plasmid pOS49.52. Spiramycin production is
indicated for all
strains.
|
Absence of polar effect after cassette excision.
We
demonstrated the absence of a polar effect after excision by studying
the restoration of spiramycin production by orf3 expression in
the orf3::att1
hyg strain
(before excision) (Fig.
3d) and in the
orf3::att1 strain (after
excision) (Fig. 3e). A DNA
fragment carrying the Streptomyces ermE* promoter upstream
from the entire orf3 coding sequence was inserted into vector
pIJ903, yielding pOS49.52. This plasmid did not restore spiramycin
production in the
orf3::att1
hyg strain,
indicating a polar effect due to disruption of the expression of the
downstream genes, whose products are necessary for spiramycin
biosynthesis (Fig.
3d).
Further experiments were carried out on two independent clones from which the cassette had been excised. The two clones were transformed with pOS49.52. Transformants were selected on R2YE medium containing Ts and further allowed to sporulate on Hickey-Tresner mediumcontaining Ts. Three independent transformants were assayed for the ability to produce spiramycin in liquid medium. All produced spiramycin at the same level as the OSC2 strain (Fig. 3e), demonstrating the absence of a polar effect due to the orf3::att1 mutation.
|
|
|---|
In this work, we have described a set of cassettes that contain antibiotic resistance genes inserted between the attL and attR sites (attL-antibiotic resistance-attR) and a set of vectors that express the Int and Xis proteins from pSAM2. A cassette can be removed from the vector as a blunt-ended fragment (EcoRV-EcoRV) and inserted into any cloned gene. The combination of cassette insertion with a deletion of the desired size in the target gene guarantees inactivation of the gene after excision of the cassette. The presence of the cassette could be selected for by the acquisition of resistance in both E. coli and Streptomyces.
This system is useful for inactivating genes of interest and for obtaining stable mutants. Because this system ultimately relies on a double crossover taking place between the cloned, mutagenized gene and its wild-type counterpart in the bacterial chromosome, this procedure will only work efficiently in those instances where the cassette is flanked on each side by at least 200 to 300 bp of DNA identical to the targeted gene (9, 11). The removal of the antibiotic resistance genes allows the markers to be recycled for successive rounds of gene inactivation. Also, if the gene is part of an operon, insertion of a cassette, especially those containing the T4 transcriptional terminators, will introduce a polar effect on the expression of downstream genes. However, if the right cassette is used, in accordance with the size of the insertion/deletion introduced in the coding sequence of the target gene, the original reading frame will be restored after excision, ensuring the unaffected expression of downstream genes.
These cassettes were originally designed to be inserted into the target gene by cloning, hence leaving a 33-, 34-, or 35-bp sequence. Although the use of only one of the cassettes is reported here, several others have been used successfully, leaving scars of the expected sizes (our unpublished results). The PCR targeting method is now widely used for studies with Streptomyces (6, 7). The cassettes described here have also been inserted successfully into target genes by PCR targeting and lambda Red-mediated recombination (our unpublished results), using previously described E. coli strains expressing red and gam (4, 27). Amplification of the cassettes containing hyg is sometimes not very efficient, probably due to the presence of the hyg gene terminator, although the PCR conditions needed to overcome this problem have been described (25). Thus, the cassettes constructed by Gust et al. (6, 7) could be used to easily generate unmarked, nonpolar, in-frame deletions in Streptomyces. By expressing the FLP recombinase in E. coli, the central part of the cassette could be removed, leaving an 81-bp sequence. The resulting construction can then be introduced into Streptomyces, with clones resulting from a single crossover being selected and then screened for double crossovers replacing the copy of the gene disrupted by the cassette with a copy containing the in-frame deletion. The cassettes described here offer a simple alternative to this method. They may also be used to generate unmarked frameshift mutations if required.
These cassettes, or derivatives of them, could be used in a wide range of bacteria. The selection of these cassettes should be possible in different organisms by using, for example, resistance markers such as the aac-4 gene, which has been expressed from its own promoter in a wide range of bacteria, including E. coli and Streptomyces. Alternatively, the multicloning site (BamHI, XhoI, HindIII, HpaI, and BglII) present in the initial plasmids (pOSV501, -502, and -503) allows the easy cloning of other selectable markers if needed. We have clearly shown that excision is very efficient both in E. coli and in Streptomyces and requires only the expression of int and xis. The expression of these two genes may be obtained easily by using suitable constructions in various bacteria. Therefore, excision could be functional in many different hosts and heterologous environments. The pSAM2 integrase has been shown to work in Mycobacteria (12, 20). The use of excisable cassettes allowing the removal of antibiotic resistance markers could increase the acceptance of genetically engineered organisms in biotechnological applications.
This work was partly supported by Sanofi-Aventis Pharma. F.K. received a fellowship from CNRS (BDI).
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»