Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, September 2006, p. 5908-5914, Vol. 72, No. 9
0099-2240/06/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/AEM.01135-06
Copyright © 2006, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Departments of Molecular Microbiology, Genetics, and Medicine, School of Medicine, Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri 63110
Received 16 May 2006/ Accepted 25 June 2006
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Three genes that have been used for contraselection in other systems are thyA (thymidylate requirement; trimethoprim sensitivity) (4, 34), sacB (sucrose sensitivity) (5, 27, 33), and rpsL (streptomycin sensitivity) (25, 33). H. pylori is naturally trimethoprim resistant. This could be ascribed to (i) its apparent lack of a thyA gene (based on BLASTP homolog searches [31]); (ii) an intrinsic resistance of its enzyme for reduced folate synthesis, an apparent dihydrofolate reductase-dihydropteroate synthase chimaera (18); and/or (iii) other factors. An early report had indicated that sacB could serve as a contraselectable marker in H. pylori but did not describe the details of efficiency or complications that may have been encountered (8). In our H. pylori sacB experiments, however, selection for resistance to a range of sucrose concentrations gave far more background growth of nominally sensitive cells than was expected based on Escherichia coli experiences (33, 34), and conditions for sucrose-based differential killing of sacB-containing H. pylori cells varied among trials (unpublished data). Other groups had also found contraselection of sacB to be difficult in H. pylori although better than having no such marker at all (T. L. Cover, unpublished data; R. Haas, unpublished data). A third contraselection strategy, implemented here, uses the rpsL (ribosomal protein S12) gene and is based on the dominance of wild-type streptomycin-sensitive (Strs) alleles to resistance-conferring mutant alleles (16, 25).
Historically, streptomycin killing has been associated with diverse effects, including membrane damage and irreversible streptomycin uptake. Paradoxically, these were all blocked by the bacteriostatic translation inhibitor chloramphenicol. This implicated the capacity to synthesize proteins, even though streptomycin also inhibited protein synthesis. Sublethal streptomycin concentrations suppressed nonsense mutations, increased mutation, and caused membrane fragility. Biochemical studies showed that streptomycin allowed the continuation of translation once begun, but with errors in translation (misreading), and that it also allowed ribosomes to bind to mRNAs but blocked them from initiating translation (10). Davis' early unifying explanation for streptomycin's lethality (10) focused on errors it induced during translation and a resultant accumulation of defective proteins. He focused in particular on membrane proteins, interpreting that defects in them were responsible for the disruption of cell membrane integrity, massive leakage of ions and molecules, and cell death. This could explain the dominance of streptomycin sensitivity over resistance, as could the binding of Strs ribosomes to mRNAs, blocking the access of resistant ribosomes to these mRNAs, failure to translate them, and their ensuing degradation (10).
Recent exquisitely detailed molecular and genetic analyses provide mechanistic understanding. Streptomycin binds several specific 16S rRNA loops and thereby diminishes ribosome flexibility and the changes in conformation that charged tRNA binding normally induces. It stabilizes a "ribosomal ambiguity" (ram) state in which there is little if any of the proofreading needed for error-free protein synthesis (7, 15, 22, 24). Protein S12, which is mutated in Strr strains, binds rRNA sequences near sites of streptomycin binding. Most positions in which change confers resistance are in S12 domains that interact with the rRNA target. In addition, most Strr mutant S12 proteins increase the accuracy of translation, apparently by destabilizing the ram state that streptomycin itself induces; the most extreme of such rpsL (S12) alleles make growth streptomycin dependent. This can be overcome by mutations in ribosomal proteins S4 and S5, that in turn stabilize the ram state in this dynamic and finely tuned ribonucleoprotein machine (7, 14).
The two S12 residues that are most frequently changed in streptomycin-resistant H. pylori are Lys43 (Lys42 in E. coli numbering), which contacts the rRNA-bound streptomycin directly, and Lys88 (Lys87 in E. coli numbering), which is nearby in the structure (7, 14, 32). Although the Lys-to-Arg changes at these codons seem to be quite innocuous (14), other amino acid replacements can markedly diminish bacterial fitness. In particular, a large fitness cost and a resulting selection for compensatory mutations in other genes have been documented in E. coli and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium using strains with Lys42 replaced with Asn (19, 26) (not Arg). More critically, the Lys88Arg replacement used here, and also the Lys43Arg allele, have each been incorporated into H. pylori strains used for mouse infections, without obvious negative effects on fitness (12, 13, 23).
Streptomycin contraselection for chromosomal gene replacement had been developed for H. pylori previously (13) but has not been much used, perhaps because very few of the Strr isolates recovered after transformation had sustained the desired replacement. This, we suspected, was due to the near identity of the strs and strr H. pylori rpsL alleles used: frequent gene conversion between them would result in unwanted Strr gene convertants vastly outnumbering the desired Strr transformants. If correct, it seemed that the rpsL gene might still be useful for H. pylori genetic engineering if the rpsL gene conversion could be reduced.
Generalized recombination (gene conversion included) depends on close matches between participating DNA molecules and is reduced by sequence divergence, even in species that, like H. pylori, lack the ability to cleave mismatch-containing (heteroduplex) DNAs (11, 20, 31). The rpsL genes of H. pylori and Campylobacter jejuni differ by some 18% in overall DNA sequence, but the encoded S12 proteins are 95% similar in amino acid sequence. The present study was initiated with an expectation or hope that H. pylori ribosomes containing the C. jejuni S12 protein would be functional and Strs and that DNA sequence divergence between the rpsL genes of C. jejuni and H. pylori would diminish gene conversion sufficiently for the effective recovery of transformants by streptomycin contraselection. The rpsL,erm (streptomycin susceptibility, erythromycin resistance) cassette that we constructed and tested in these studies is diagrammed in Fig. 1.
|
View larger version (3K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Structure of the 1.5-kb rpsL,erm cassette, which confers dominant streptomycin susceptibility and selectable erythromycin resistance. Open boxes designate open reading frames; solid line indicates noncoding sequences. The cassette contains 272 bp of C. jejuni sequence upstream of the C. jejuni rpsL gene (408 bp), a 145-bp spacer, and then the 735-nucleotide erm gene.
|
|
|
|---|
1 µg of genomic DNA or PCR product to a lawn of cells growing exponentially on nonselective medium and, after overnight incubation, restreaking the population on selective (streptomycin- or erythromycin-containing) medium to obtain transformant colonies. Standard methods were used for PCR and for sequencing of the PCR products (2, 30). Four unrelated H. pylori strains were used here, each chosen because it is much used in other molecular genetic studies: the genome-sequenced reference strain 26695 (31), which we use to identify the numerous genes that contribute to high-level metronidazole resistance (2); unrelated strains SS1 and X47 (X47 was originally called X47-2AL) (12, 17), which colonize mice, preferentially occupy different regions of the stomach (1, 28), and differ in the phenotypic consequences of inactivation of at least certain metabolic genes (30); and G27MA, a cell-culture-adapted derivative of the G27 strain that is frequently used for studies of H. pylori-host cell interaction (3) and that can efficiently colonize DBA/2 mice (W.-K. Lee, D. Dailidiene, and D. E. Berg, unpublished data). The erm gene used in the rpsL,erm cassette (Fig. 1) was originally from plasmid pRH151, kindly provided by Rainer Haas, and was matched in sequence to that of pNE131 (GenBank accession no. NC_001390). The C. jejuni rpsL gene used in this cassette was from plasmid pDRF265, kindly provided by David Hendrixson and Victor DiRita.
To prepare for the development and testing of the rpsL,erm cassette, an strr allele of the normal chromosomal H. pylori rpsL gene was constructed and introduced into strain 26695 to generate 26695-str. This was achieved by PCR of rpsL DNA from 26695 with the primers rpsL1 and rpsL2 (Table 1) to generate a 203-bp PCR product that contained the A-to-G changes at each of the two sites most frequently responsible for streptomycin resistance (codons 43 and 88; Lys to Arg in each case) (32). This product was used to transform strain 26695 to streptomycin resistance to generate "26695-str." PCR-based DNA sequencing showed that each of several such 26695-str transformants contained an A-to-G change at nucleotide position 263 but was wild type at nucleotide position 129 (i.e., a change of Lys to Arg at codon 88 only). Genomic DNA from one such transformant was used to transform SS1 and G27MA to streptomycin resistance (generating SS1-str and G27MA-str). Strain X47 is already streptomycin resistant (10) and was found to contain the same rpsL A263G (Lys88Arg) allele.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. PCR primers used in this study and features of their amplification products
|
20 bp at the ends of DNAs to be joined together, which, in turn, result from the design of PCR primers used in amplification (see Table 1, sequences in italics) (6, 29).
To construct the rpsL,erm cassette, we first replaced the mdaB quinone reductase gene in the H. pylori chromosome with the erm gene and then used genomic DNA carrying this
mdaB-erm allele for PCR to insert the C. jejuni rpsL gene just upstream of erm. Each of these manipulations involved a three-fragment assembly as in Fig. 2, transformation and selection for erythromycin resistance (Ermr), and PCR verification of structure. Two sequential three fragment assemblies were used because three-fragment assemblies have been more reliable for us than four-fragment assemblies.
![]() View larger version (10K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Construction of insertion and deletion alleles by assembly of three fragments with overlapping ends. Half arrows indicate the positions of the primers, whose sequences are given in Table 1. Segments A and C represent DNA segments flanking the locus to be deleted or the site of insertion (depending on needs of experiment). Segment B represents (i) the erm (resistance) gene used initially to replace the mdaB locus; (ii) the rpsL streptomycin susceptibility gene from C. jejuni that was inserted just upstream of erm in a strain carrying erm in place of mdaB; or (iii) the rpsL,erm cassette, which can be moved to many loci.
|
mdaB-erm allele.
The C. jejuni rpsL gene was inserted upstream of erm in the
mdaB-erm allele to generate the 1.5-kb rpsL,erm cassette (Fig. 1). This was achieved by amplification of three PCR products and their assembly into a composite PCR product (again as in Fig. 2 and Table 1), use of this product to transform strain 26695-str, selection of Ermr transformant colonies, and identification of those products that had become phenotypically Strs. In terms of the depiction in Fig. 2, fragment A contained sequences just upstream of erm in the
mdaB-erm allele; fragment C contained erm and also H. pylori sequences downstream of mdaB; and fragment B contained the Cj.rpsL (strs allele) gene. PCR of the mixture of segments A, B, and C with primers 1 and 6 yielded the desired 2.5-kb assembly.
Replacements of genes frxA, fur, and nikR with the rpsL,erm cassette were made similarly by (i) using DNAs from upstream and downstream of these target genes (amplified with appropriate primers 1 and 2 and primers 5 and 6) and also from the rpsL,erm cassette (amplified with primers 3 and 4); (ii) assembly from the three-fragment mixture using the appropriate locus-specific primers 1 and 6 (Table 1); (iii) transformation of 26695-str, selection of Ermr colonies, and identification of those that were phenotypically Strs; and (iv) verification by PCR of the replacement of wild-type alleles by the rpsL,erm-marked deletion alleles.
|
|
|---|
mdaB-rpsL,erm) was constructed by PCR (Fig. 2) and recovered in the H. pylori chromosome after the transformation of 26695-str (see Materials and Methods). PCR tests showed that each of four Ermr Strs transformants tested contained the expected
mdaB-rpsL,erm allele in place of the full-length mdaB gene. Streaks of such colonies to streptomycin-containing agar typically yielded a few Strr derivative colonies after prolonged incubation. This slight instability is not seen in haploid strains containing only an rpsL-strs allele. These rare Strr derivatives remained Ermr and, based on PCR tests, retained the
mdaB-rpsL,erm allele in place of mdaB. These derivatives likely result from occasional gene conversion, despite H. pylori-C. jejuni rpsL sequence divergence.
In initial characterizations, nine recipient populations, each representing a different Strs
mdaB-rpsL,erm transformant of 26695-str, were used for transformation with genomic DNAs from wild-type 26695. About 30 Strr colonies from each transformation were streaked with toothpicks to erythromycin-containing agar: between 63 and 96% of Strr colonies obtained were Erms (average, 84% ± 13%) (Table 2). PCR tests confirmed
mdaB-rpsL,erm replacement by full-length mdaB in each of eight Strr Erms colonies tested, and retention of
mdaB-rpsL,erm in four Strr Ermr colonies, as expected (Fig. 3). In related tests, PCR products containing full-length mdaB plus several hundred base pairs of flanking sequences (made with mdaB primers 1 and 6; Table 1) were used in equivalent transformations of
mdaB-rpsL,erm derivatives of 26695-str or isogenic metronidazole-resistant strains (mutation in mdaB is implicated in the development of high-level metronidazole resistance [2]). Approximately 30 to 86% of the Strr colonies obtained (average of 68%; ten transformations) were of the desired Erms type.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Yields of Erms isolates among Strr colonies after transformationa
|
![]() View larger version (20K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Strategy for the use of rpsL from C. jejuni as a contraselectable determinant of streptomycin susceptibility in H. pylori. Diagrammed here is a recipient strain carrying an strr allele of its normal (H. pylori) rpsL gene and also the rpsL,erm cassette that had (in an earlier transformation) replaced the mdaB gene, now being transformed with genomic DNA from a strain with full-length mdaB, and acquisition of mdaB plus flanking sequences by crossing over in regions of sequence homology. This results in replacement of the rpsL,erm cassette and a change from Ermr to Erms in phenotype. Unwanted gene conversion events also result in an Strr phenotype, but the Ermr phenotype is retained.
|
mdaB-rpsL,erm allele was moved by transformation into the streptomycin-resistant (rpsL) strains SS1-str, G27MA-str, and X47 by using genomic DNA from 26695-str
mdaB-rpsL,erm and selection for erythromycin resistance. Each of the
30 Ermr transformants in each of these strains were Strs, as expected. Two
mdaB-rpsL,erm derivatives of each strain, found by PCR to have the expected structure, were used as recipients in transformations with DNA from isogenic wild-type parents. Table 2 shows that the yields of Strr Erms transformants among Strr colonies ranged from
21% in the case of G27MA-str to 88% in the case of X47.
To further test the general utility of this contraselection strategy, we constructed deletion alleles marked with the rpsL,erm cassette of three other genesfrxA (nitroreductase), fur (iron- and pH-responsive regulation), and nikR (nickel-responsive regulation)by PCR (Fig. 2) and transformation of 26695-str (Materials and Methods). DNAs from transformants with the desired Strs phenotypes and PCR-verified structures were then used to move each rpsL,erm-tagged deletion allele to the three other strains (G27MA-str, SS1-str, and X47). The yields of Ermr Strs transformants among Ermr colonies made with these genomic DNAs varied from
50% to
100% (data not shown). Since just one genomic DNA preparation for each locus was used to move a given allele among H. pylori strains (in each case from the 26695-str derivative), this variation in Strs colony yield might reflect an interplay of the strain background (e.g., nuclease or DNA repair activities) and the sequence of the transforming DNA and/or the targeted region.
These new rpsL,erm-marked strains were then transformed with isogenic wild-type genomic DNAs, and Strr colonies were selected and tested as described above. Table 2 shows that the yields of Erms Strr transformants among Strr colonies varied with the locus under study (from
17% to
90%) and with the strain background. PCR tests of a few representative Strr Erms transformants of each of these various rpsL,erm-marked deletion strains verified the expected replacement of the rpsL,erm allele in each case.
|
|
|---|
Our results with four rpsL,erm-marked loci in four unrelated strains suggest that this cassette can be placed at any nonessential site in H. pylori strains of interest. Once inserted, other DNAs can be moved to that marked locus by transformation and homologous recombination. The desired transformants are identified simply by screening a relatively few Strr colonies to identify those with the desired Erms phenotype. The yields of these replacements among selected Strr colonies varied from
17% to
90%, depending on the gene targeted and the strain background. That this variation was seen with genomic DNAs from isogenic wild-type donor strains indicates that it is not due to DNA restriction. Rather, it may reflect local and genomewide effects on relative efficiencies of transformation versus gene conversion between related but divergent sequences. If further improvement in efficiency were needed, this could likely be achieved with a synthetic rpsL gene that is even more divergent from the H. pylori rpsL in DNA sequence (to further inhibit gene conversion), while exploiting the degeneracy of the code to ensure that it still encodes an H. pylori-like S12 protein.
In other experiments to date, we used this rpsL,erm cassette to replace point mutant alleles with wild-type alleles and vice versa, to replace full-length genes with unmarked deletion alleles, and to create a novel triple mutant allele of the fur regulatory gene (itself generated by PCR without cloning) for functional analyses of iron and pH-responsive transcriptional regulation. We anticipate additional applications for this cassette, including (i) the functional characterization of genes from divergent clinical isolates; (ii) altering key regulatory sites; (iii) engineering new domains or epitopes in surface-exposed or -secreted proteins; (iv) adding new genes to genomes of interest; and (v) deletion or other changes in some or all members of multigene families, unimpeded by the numbers of changes that might be needed.
This study was supported by grants RO1 DK063041 and P30 DK52574 from the U.S. National Institutes of Health.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»