Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, September 2006, p. 6117-6123, Vol. 72, No. 9
0099-2240/06/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/AEM.00773-06
Copyright © 2006, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
University of Naples Federico II, Department of Food Science, Division of Microbiology, Portici (Naples), Italy,1 University of Münster, Institute of Medical Microbiology, Münster, Germany2
Received 3 April 2006/ Accepted 23 June 2006
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Primarily, five major serological types, SEA through SEE, have been characterized (6). In the past years, many new types of SEs and their coding genes (seg through seu) have been reported (12, 16, 17, 19, 27, 30-33, 37, 37, 39, 40). However, some of the novel SE homologues were shown to be nonemetic, thus actually lacking the defining property of SEs and consequently designated "staphylococcal enterotoxin-like" superantigens (20). For SEC, minor variants have been reported (23). The staphylococcal PTSAgs constitute a large family of structurally related proteins whose genes are associated with mobile genetic elements. SEB, SEC, SEG, SEI, SEM, SEN, SEO, SEK, SEL, SEQ, and TSS toxin 1 are encoded by pathogenicity islands (2, 16, 17, 21). SEA, SEE, and SEP are encoded by prophages (7, 10, 17), whereas SED, SEJ, and SER are encoded by a plasmid known as pIB485 (3, 29, 40). The association with mobile genetic elements implies a horizontal transfer of the PTSAg genes between staphylococcal strains and an important role in the evolution of S. aureus as a pathogen.
Sequencing of the seg-sei intergenic DNA and flanking regions revealed three enterotoxin-like open reading frames related to seg and sei, designated sen, seo, and sem, and two pseudogenes,
ent1 and
ent2. Moreover, it was shown that these genes belong to an operon designated the enterotoxin gene cluster (egc), comprising seo, sem, sei,
ent1-
ent2, sen, and seg (16). In addition, minor variants for seg and, limited to one strain, for sei were reported recently (1, 8). Due to sequence divergences in the
ent1-
ent2 pseudogenes, the seu gene (including a variant) was described as a further part of the egc cluster (19). Consequently, at least three different egc subtypes were suggested: (i) egc1 (harboring seo, sem, sei,
ent1,
ent2, sen, and seg), as represented by strain A900322 (GenBank accession number AF285760), (ii) egc2 (containing seu instead of
ent1 and
ent2), as represented by strain FRI 137 (GenBank accession number AY205306), and (iii) egc3 (containing sei, seu, sen, and seg variants), as represented by strain 382F (GenBank accession number AY158703).
Recent studies, comprising isolates recovered from different human and veterinary specimens, showed that egc and its carried SE genes are more common in S. aureus strains than assumed so far (4, 5, 15, 26, 36).
Increasingly, S. aureus typing has become an important tool in the study of strain origin, clonal relatedness, and the epidemiology of outbreaks. Although several different phenotypic and, more recently, molecular techniques are available for differentiating S. aureus strains, no method is clearly superior under all conditions.
Previous studies (15-16) have shown that egc SE genes are arranged in tandem orientation in the egc cluster and are coexpressed. egc-encoded superantigens from Staphylococcus aureus are neutralized by human sera much less efficiently than are classical staphylococcal enterotoxins and toxic shock syndrome toxin (14). Moreover SEG and SEI interact differently with major histocompatibility complex class II and stimulate completely different subsets of human and mouse T cells. These characteristics indicate complementary superantigenic activity and suggest an important advantage to staphylococcal strains in producing both SEG and SEI.
Therefore, analyzing the diversity of staphylococcal PTSAgs may enhance our knowledge of the pathogenicity and evolution of S. aureus and improve detection approaches for diagnostic purposes and epidemiological studies.
The purpose of this study was to analyze the genetic variability within the egc cluster by restriction endonucleases analysis (REA) and nucleotide sequencing of a collection of S. aureus strains recovered from different human sources and food samples. The discrimination power of this technique was evaluated by comparing its results with those obtained by spa typing, which is widely used for biotyping S. aureus strains.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Source, origin and results of egc characterization and spa typing of strains analyzed in this study
|
DNA isolation.
Following overnight incubation in brain heart infusion broth (Oxoid, Basingstoke, Hampshire, United Kingdom), staphylococcal cells were streaked on brain heart infusion agar plates and incubated overnight at 37°C. DNA extraction was carried out from a single colony by using the InstaGene matrix (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Hercules, CA) according to the manufacturer's recommendations. About 25 ng of DNA was used for PCR amplification.
PCR amplification of the S. aureus egc.
The egc operon was detected by using PCR primers SEI-1 and SEG-2 as previously described by McLauchlin et al. (25) (Table 2), amplifying a 3,375-bp fragment comprising 47 nucleotides of sem, the complete nucleotide sequences of sei,
ent1-
ent2 (or seu), and sen followed by 610 nucleotides of seg.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. PCR primers used in this study
|
REA of S. aureus egc cluster.
REA of the amplification fragments of the primer pair SEI-1 and SEG-2 was performed by digestion of about 1 µg (30 to 35 µl) of the PCR product with 20 U of the following restriction enzymes (in a total volume of 50 µl): EcoRI, AluI, TaqI, and CfoI (Promega Italia, Milan, Italy). Restriction digests were resolved by agarose (2% wt/vol) gel electrophoresis at 80 V for 3 h.
PCR detection of the individual SE genes of the egc cluster.
seo, sem, sei, sen, and seg genes were detected by using the following primer pairs: SEO-1 and SEO-2, SEM-1 and SEM-2, SEI-1 and SEI-2, SEN-1 and SEN-2, and SEG-1 and SEG-2 (Table 1). The
1-
2 pseudogenes and seu were detected by the use of the primer pairs PSE-1 plus PSE-4 and PSE-2 plus PSE-4, respectively, as previously published by Letertre et al. (19) (Table 2).
Sequencing procedures of sei, and seg genes.
The 3,375-bp SEI-1/SEG-2 amplification fragments were used for sequencing the sei and seg genes. In the case of weak amplification products (Table 3), the primer pairs SEI-1/SEI-4 and SEG-1/SEG-4 (Table 2) were used alternatively. sei/seg PCR was performed as described above, while PCR cycling conditions were 94°C for 3 min, followed by 30 cycles of 94°C for 5 s and 53°C for 1 min and finally 72°C for 5 min.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. PCR egc characterization of strains showing SEI-1/SEG-2 weak amplification bands
|
spa typing.
The x region of the spa gene was amplified by PCR with primers 1095F and 1517R as previously described by Shopsin et al. (35). DNA sequences were obtained by an ABI 377 sequencer (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, Calif.). spa types were determined with the software Ridom StaphType (13) by using the Ridom SpaServer (http://spa.ridom.de/).
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers.
All sequences determined in this study were deposited in GenBank under accession numbers AY920260, AY920261, AY920259, AY920257, AY920262, AY920256, AY920258, DQ778337, DQ778338, AY920264, AY920265, AY920263, AY920269, AY920266, AY920267, and AY920268.
|
|
|---|
REA of S. aureus egc cluster.
Fig. 1 (panels B, C, D, and E) shows the different REA patterns of the 29 egc-positive strains obtained from digestions of the 3,375-bp PCR fragment using EcoRI, TaqI, AluI, and CfoI. According to the results obtained by REA, the strains were classified into seven groups (Table 4). Three groups were associated with strains possessing the previously described three types of the egc operon (Table 1): (i) REA-1, comprising A900322 known to harbor egc1, other reference strains, and food-borne isolates, (ii) REA-2, restricted to FRI 137 and known to harbor egc2, and (iii) REA-3, restricted to 382F and known to possess egc3. Further REA groups (Table 1), such as REA-4, found in veterinary and food origin isolates, REA-5, shown for ATCC 25923, REA-6, observed for AB8802, as well as REA-7, comprising several isolates of human and veterinary origin, represent S. aureus strains which may harbor putative novel types of the egc operon (designated egc4, egc5, egc6, and egc7, respectively).
![]() View larger version (66K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Specific PCR detection and REA characterization of S. aureus egc. Panel A shows the 3,375-bp PCR fragment obtained by amplifying the S. aureus egc of strains FRI137 (lane 1), NCTC 9393 (lane 2), RIMD 31092 (lane 3), and AB-8802 (lane 4). Panels B, C, D, and E show different restriction endonuclease patterns obtained from digestions of the 3,375-bp PCR fragment from egc-positive strains with EcoRI, TaqI, AluI, and CfoI, respectively. M1, 1-Kb DNA Ladder Plus (Invitrogen SRL); M2, 1-Kb DNA Ladder (Invitrogen SRL).
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 4. REA egc patterns shown by strains of the same egc group
|
ent1-
ent2 and seu, respectively.
Analysis of strains with weak SEI-1/SEG-2 amplicons.
The two strains providing weak SEI-1/SEG-2 amplification results using primers as previously described (8, 25) tested PCR positive for seo, sem, and sen, negative for seg and seu, and variable for sei. Thus, these strains were grouped into two different toxin genotypes differing in the possession of sei (Table 3). However, a positive sei PCR result was detected in these strains by applying SEI-1 (25) in combination with the newly designed primer SEI-4, which targets an alternative egc position. Also, seg tested PCR positive for these strains by using a further newly designed primer (SEG-4) along with SEG-1 (25).
Sequencing of seg and sei fragments.
The sei and seg regions of strains giving weak amplification results were sequenced and compared to the sequencing results of the respective sequences of other strains known to harbor seg and sei (Fig. 2, panel A and B, respectively). The accession numbers of the sei and seg gene sequences analyzed in this study are given in Fig. 2. Dendrograms, as depicted in Fig. 2, demonstrate the relationships of the sequences. In both panels of Fig. 2, strains were clearly gathered in two separate clusters based on the percentage of identities. In addition to the prototype seg and sei, variant types, called the seg and sei variants, were found for both genes. Moreover, a low-grade polymorphism was revealed for seg, the seg variant, and sei, but not for the sei variant. In particular, two nucleotide changes were found for seg (a G
T substitution at position 5442 and a A
G substitution at position 5450; the nucleotide numbering was previously described by Jarraud et al. [16]) in strains 10 and 107 in the binding site of primer SEG-2, explaining the negative amplification results obtained by the SEI-1/SEG-2 and SEG-1/SEG2 primer sets.
![]() View larger version (21K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Nucleotide sequence identities of seg (panel A) and sei (panel B) genes as analyzed in this study. n.d., not determined; n.g., not given.
|
spa typing.
A total of 19 spa types were obtained by analyzing the 35 strains included in this study (Table 1). In both directions, there was no general concordance between the affiliation to a REA egc group and the spa type of a given isolate. On one hand, the strains of the REA egc groups 1 (n = 11), 4 (n = 4), and 7 (n = 10) displayed three, two, and seven different spa types, respectively. On the other hand, some strains exhibiting the same spa type were shown to differ by their REA egc polymorphism. The three reference strains A900322, NCTC 9393, and RIMD 31092 as well as the two veterinary strains, 105 and 106, exhibiting the t002 spa type, fitted into the two different REA egc groups 1 and 4, respectively. Also, the reference strain ATCC 25923, the food-derived strain AB-8802, and the human-derived strain 7645a, harboring the t021 spa type, were shown to belong to three different REA egc groups (REA-5, -6, and -7, respectively). Moreover, in other cases, as expected, strains isolated from the same source showed the same spa type and REA egc group: (i) strains AS14 and AS27 were isolated from the same sample A; (ii) strains SI9, SI1, LA 14, and R1 from the same plant A; (iii) strains ED3 and ED4 from the same sample ED; and (iv) strains 105 and 106 from the same machine.
|
|
|---|
ent1 and
ent2, (16). Furthermore, reverse transcription-PCR experiments revealed that all of these genes belong to one operon, designated the enterotoxin gene cluster (egc) (16). To rule out possible confusion with SEs described at the same time (12, 32), the sek and sel genes were renamed sen and seo, respectively, as published in a correction note (16). Mempel et al. showed that egc occurs in about 48% of the SE-positive S. aureus strains isolated from atopic eczema (26). Recently, we detected this cluster in S. aureus strains isolated from food samples (8). Moreover, genes of the egc cluster were found in isolates recovered from nasal and blood specimens in high percentages (4, 5). Recently, by applying the microarray technology for simultaneous detection of the SE genes, Sergeev et al. (34) estimated that about 92% of S. aureus strains contain multiple SE genes (especially the egc cluster genes). Surveys of the egc distribution in S. aureus strains of animal origin also demonstrated a high frequency of egc-like genes (36).
However, based on several studies, it has been assumed that differences in the possession of individual genes or nucleotide variations may occur for the SE genes of the egc cluster (4, 5, 8, 14, 16, 19). In particular, Letertre et al. (19) found a 15-bp insertion in
ent1 and some point mutations in both
ent1 and
ent2 of the strains FRI 137 and 382F with respect to these two pseudogenes of strain A900322 originally described by Jarraud et al. (16). Instead of allowing translation of the pseudogenes (
ent1 and
ent2), this insertion allowed a putative 261-nucleotide open reading frame (named seu) to be translated (19). In addition, it was demonstrated that egc of strain 382F is characterized by variants of the sei, seu, sen, and seg genes (19). This seg allele was shown to be identical to the previously characterized seg variant (1). A further SEGL29P variant was reported by Jarraud et al. (16).
We recently showed that some egc-positive strains, derived from food samples, were negative using PCR assays designed for sei and/or seg (8). Those strains displayed a egc restriction pattern compared to those of other egc-positive strains. Partial nucleotide sequencing of the sei and seg genes in strain AB-8802 (egc+, sei negative, and seg negative) confirmed the mispriming of both reverse sei primer (SEI-2) and forward seg primer (SEG-1) used in the PCR amplifications. We also found that approximately 30% of the S. aureus strains tested showed a positive sei amplification result by PCR, but they failed in subsequent hybridization reactions with sei-specific probes using a generic DNA enzyme immunoassay system (4). In this study, two strains (10 and 107) of veterinary origin showed weak amplification using primers SEI-1 and SEG-2 but tested PCR positive using newly designed egc primers, suggesting that the binding sites of the original primer may be polymorphic. The last hypothesis was corroborated by the sequence analysis of sei and seg genes of 10 and 107 S. aureus strains. The full sei gene sequences of AB-8802 and 7645a S. aureus strains showed 100% identity with the sei variant gene of strain 382F (GenBank accession number AF064774 [19]), while their full-nucleotide seg gene sequences displayed 99% identity (AB-8802) with the seg variant gene as previously described by Abe et al. (1).
In addition, we analyzed a part of the egc operon (sem-seg segment) of food-borne, human, veterinary, and reference S. aureus strains by REA using EcoRI, CfoI, AluI, and TaqI, allowing the differentiation of at least seven different egc operons. Thus, REA of the egc operon was shown to be successful in typing and analyzing egc-positive S. aureus strains. Sequence analysis of the putative new egc types may provide further insight into the evolution of egc, which was recently identified as a highly prevalent operon of enterotoxin genes, forming a putative nursery of superantigens in S. aureus.
The high level of polymorphism of the S. aureus egc, as detected by REA analysis of the SEI-1/SEG-2 PCR fragment and confirmed by DNA sequencing, was shown. The egc polymorphism seems to be unrelated to the evolution of S. aureus, as demonstrated by spa typing. In addition to the recently described three egc operons, four further variants were characterized. In particular, a variant of sei, called the sei variant, detectable in several S. aureus strains was delineated. Furthermore, the previously described seg variant was shown to occur frequently in a defined S. aureus strain collection. The observed polymorphism was due to point mutations causing loss or generation of restriction endonuclease sites or DNA insertions as described elsewhere. Moreover, this distinct polymorphism may explain the existence of strains possessing only some of the egc-carried genes or pseudogenes. Furthermore, failures in the detection of the egc cluster may occur, especially if the primer pair SEI-1/SEG2 is used. This should be considered, particularly for PCR approaches for diagnostic purposes and epidemiological studies, although it may be avoided by the application of the PSE-1/PSE-4 primers (19), which target regions representing highly conserved parts of the cluster.
During this study, the possibility of exploiting the egc polymorphism for epidemiological studies was evaluated by comparing results obtained by REA of the egc operon with those by spa typing. Although more limited than REA by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis analysis in discriminatory power, spa typing is often used as a screening method for typing S. aureus strains due to its shorter turnaround time, ease of use, and inherent advantages of sequence analysis, storage, and information sharing (35).
Our results reveal higher discriminatory power of spa typing in biotyping S. aureus egc-positive strains than that of REA egc. On the other hand, the REA egc analysis' capability to discriminate, in some cases, among strains showing the same spa type, even though they were geographically related, makes it a reliable typing tool. Therefore, by using a polyphasic approach, including both REA of egc and spa typing analyses, the biotyping of egc-positive S. aureus strains can be reliably achieved, furnishing, at the same time, knowledge of great consequence about the potential toxicity of S. aureus strains.
Financial support was provided by the MIPAF of Italy (project SIQUALTECA) and the German Network of Competence "Pathogenomics," Alliance "Gram-Positive Cocci."
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»